B.J. Surhoff vs Melky Cabrera

B.J. Surhoff and Melky Cabrera compared on their MLB careers: B.J. Surhoff played 19 seasons, 1987 to 2005, Melky Cabrera 15 seasons, 2005 to 2019. B.J. Surhoff has .282 batting average to Melky Cabrera's .285. Melky Cabrera won 2 titles.

Who has the better career numbers?

B.J. Surhoff and Melky Cabrera career totals

2,313	GP	1,887
8,258	AB	6,878
1,062	R	895
2,326	H	1,962
188	HR	144
1,153	RBI	854
141	SB	101
0.3	AVG	0.3
0.3	OBP	0.3
0.4	SLG	0.4
0.7	OPS	0.8

How do they compare in the postseason?

B.J. Surhoff and Melky Cabrera postseason

27	GP	25
90	AB	83
6	R	8
24	H	17
4	HR	1
12	RBI	7
1	SB	0
0.3	AVG	0.2
0.3	OBP	0.2
0.4	SLG	0.3
0.7	OPS	0.5

Where each stands all time

B.J. Surhoff and Melky Cabrera all-time places

147th (2,326)	Hits	—
170th (1,153)	RBI	—

Among the MLB players with a career line on file, regular season, counting stats only — the same lists the records pages run on.

Titles and awards

B.J. Surhoff: 0 championships; none on file
Melky Cabrera: 2 championships; none on file

Awards come from the league’s published winner lists; a championship counts a season played for the club that won it.

Season by season

Lined up by career year, not by calendar: each row is the players’ nth season.

B.J. Surhoff and Melky Cabrera season by season

1st	1987	.299	7	68	2005	.211	0	0
2nd	1988	.245	5	38	2006	.280	7	50
3rd	1989	.248	5	55	2007	.273	8	73
4th	1990	.276	6	59	2008	.249	8	37
5th	1991	.289	5	68	2009	.274	13	68
6th	1992	.252	4	62	2010	.255	4	42
7th	1993	.274	7	79	2011	.305	18	87
8th	1994	.261	5	22	2012	.346	11	60
9th	1995	.320	13	73	2013	.279	3	30
10th	1996	.292	21	82	2014	.301	16	73
11th	1997	.284	18	88	2015	.273	12	77
12th	1998	.279	22	92	2016	.296	14	86
13th	1999	.308	28	107	2017	.285	17	85
14th	2000	.291	14	68	2018	.280	6	39
15th	2001	.271	10	58	2019	.280	7	47
16th	2002	.293	0	9	—	—	—	—
17th	2003	.295	5	41	—	—	—	—
18th	2004	.309	8	50	—	—	—	—
19th	2005	.257	5	34	—	—	—	—

What the columns mean: AVG · HR · RBI


27	GP	25
90	AB	83
6	R	8
24	H	17
4	HR	1
12	RBI	7
1	SB	0
0.3	AVG	0.2
0.3	OBP	0.2
0.4	SLG	0.3
0.7	OPS	0.5


27	GP	25
90	AB	83
6	R	8
24	H	17
4	HR	1
12	RBI	7
1	SB	0
0.3	AVG	0.2
0.3	OBP	0.2
0.4	SLG	0.3
0.7	OPS	0.5


27	GP	25
90	AB	83
6	R	8
24	H	17
4	HR	1
12	RBI	7
1	SB	0
0.3	AVG	0.2
0.3	OBP	0.2
0.4	SLG	0.3
0.7	OPS	0.5