Andrew McCutchen vs Chase Utley

Andrew McCutchenChase Utley

Andrew McCutchen and Chase Utley compared on their MLB careers: Andrew McCutchen played 18 seasons, 2009 to 2026, Chase Utley 16 seasons, 2003 to 2018. Andrew McCutchen has .271 batting average to Chase Utley's .275. Chase Utley won 1 title.

Who has the better career numbers?

Andrew McCutchen and Chase Utley career totals
2,299GP1,937
8,423AB6,857
1,298R1,103
2,280H1,885
333HR259
1,157RBI1,025
220SB154
0.3AVG0.3
0.4OBP0.4
0.5SLG0.5
0.8OPS0.8

How do they compare in the postseason?

Andrew McCutchen and Chase Utley postseason
13GP68
46AB210
5R41
11H47
0HR10
1RBI27
0SB11
0.2AVG0.2
0.3OBP0.4
0.3SLG0.4
0.6OPS0.8

Where each stands all time

Andrew McCutchen and Chase Utley all-time places
121st (333)Home runs239th (259)
161st (2,280)Hits—
168th (1,157)RBI246th (1,025)

Among the MLB players with a career line on file, regular season, counting stats only — the same lists the records pages run on.

Titles and awards

  • Andrew McCutchen: 0 championships; NL Gold Glove, NL Silver Slugger ×4, NL MVP
  • Chase Utley: 1 championship; NL Silver Slugger ×4

Awards come from the league’s published winner lists; a championship counts a season played for the club that won it.

Season by season

Lined up by career year, not by calendar: each row is the players’ nth season.

Andrew McCutchen and Chase Utley season by season
AVG: Hits per at-bat. .300 is the traditional line between a good hitter and a great one.HR: Home runs hit.RBI: Runs that scored because of this batter's plate appearance.AVG: Hits per at-bat. .300 is the traditional line between a good hitter and a great one.HR: Home runs hit.RBI: Runs that scored because of this batter's plate appearance.
1st2009.28612542003.239221
2nd2010.28616562004.2661357
3rd2011.25923892005.29128105
4th2012.32731962006.30932102
5th2013.31721842007.33222103
6th2014.31425832008.29233104
7th2015.29223962009.2823193
8th2016.25624792010.2751665
9th2017.27928882011.2591144
10th2018.25520652012.2561145
11th2019.25610292013.2841869
12th2020.25310342014.2701178
13th2021.22227802015.212839
14th2022.23717692016.2521452
15th2023.25612432017.236834
16th2024.23220502018.213114
17th2025.2391357————
18th2026.19215————

What the columns mean: AVG · HR · RBI