 Jon Kitna | Cincinnati Bengals 2001-2005, Dallas Cowboys 2009-2013 | 9 | 1 award |
 Damar Hamlin | Buffalo Bills 2022-2026 | 5 | 1 award |
 Odell Beckham Jr. | Los Angeles Rams 2021, Baltimore Ravens 2023, Miami Dolphins 2024 | 3 | 1 award |
 Robert Griffin III | Baltimore Ravens 2018-2019, Baltimore Ravens 2020 | 3 | 1 award |
 Geno Smith | New York Giants 2017, Los Angeles Chargers 2018 | 2 | 1 award |
 Matt Bryant | Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2005-2008, Atlanta Falcons 2009-2019 | 15 | — |
 Stephen Gostkowski | New England Patriots 2006-2019, Tennessee Titans 2020 | 15 | — |
 Derek Anderson | Cleveland Browns 2005-2009, Arizona Cardinals 2010, Carolina Panthers 2011-2017, Buffalo Bills 2018 | 14 | — |
 Josh Brown | Seattle Seahawks 2003-2007, Los Angeles Rams 2008-2011, Cincinnati Bengals 2012, New York Giants 2013-2016 | 14 | — |
 Matt Stover | Baltimore Ravens 1996-2008, Indianapolis Colts 2009 | 14 | — |
 Russell Wilson | Seattle Seahawks 2012-2021, Denver Broncos 2022-2023, Pittsburgh Steelers 2024, New York Giants 2025 | 14 | — |
 John Carney | Los Angeles Chargers 1996-2000, New Orleans Saints 2001-2010 | 13 | — |
 Kris Brown | Pittsburgh Steelers 1999-2001, Houston Texans 2002-2009, Los Angeles Chargers 2010 | 12 | — |
 Jeff Reed | Pittsburgh Steelers 2002-2010, San Francisco 49ers 2010 | 10 | — |
 Wil Lutz | New Orleans Saints 2016-2022, Denver Broncos 2024-2026 | 10 | — |
 Mark Royals | Detroit Lions 1996, New Orleans Saints 1997-1998, Tampa Bay Buccaneers 1999-2001, Miami Dolphins 2002-2003, Jacksonville Jaguars 2003 | 9 | — |
 Carson Palmer | Las Vegas Raiders 2011-2012, Arizona Cardinals 2013-2017 | 7 | — |
 C.J. Beathard | San Francisco 49ers 2017-2020, Jacksonville Jaguars 2021-2023 | 7 | — |
 Jack Fox | Detroit Lions 2020-2026 | 7 | — |
 Brad Daluiso | New York Giants 1996-2000, Las Vegas Raiders 2001 | 6 | — |
 Brandon Weeden | Cleveland Browns 2012-2013, Dallas Cowboys 2014-2015, Tennessee Titans 2017, Houston Texans 2018 | 6 | — |
 Budda Baker | Arizona Cardinals 2021-2026 | 6 | — |
 Dustin Hopkins | Washington Commanders 2015-2020 | 6 | — |
 Jeff George | Las Vegas Raiders 1997-1998, Minnesota Vikings 1999, Washington Commanders 2000-2001, Seattle Seahawks 2002 | 6 | — |
 Joey Harrington | Detroit Lions 2002-2005, Miami Dolphins 2006, New Orleans Saints 2008 | 6 | — |
 Rick Mirer | Seattle Seahawks 1996, New York Jets 1999, San Francisco 49ers 2000-2001, Las Vegas Raiders 2002-2003 | 6 | — |
 Al Del Greco | Tennessee Titans 1996-2000 | 5 | — |
 Blair Walsh | Minnesota Vikings 2012-2016 | 5 | — |
 Derwin James Jr. | Los Angeles Chargers 2022-2026 | 5 | — |
 EJ Manuel | Buffalo Bills 2013-2015, Buffalo Bills 2016, Las Vegas Raiders 2017 | 5 | — |
 Jameis Winston | Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2015-2019 | 5 | — |
 Jay Feely | Miami Dolphins 2007, New York Jets 2008-2009, Arizona Cardinals 2011-2012 | 5 | — |
 Landry Jones | Pittsburgh Steelers 2013-2017 | 5 | — |
 Richie Cunningham | Dallas Cowboys 1997-1999, Carolina Panthers 1999-2000 | 5 | — |
 Adam Podlesh | Jacksonville Jaguars 2007-2010 | 4 | — |
 Billy Cundiff | Dallas Cowboys 2002-2005 | 4 | — |
| Jesse Palmer | New York Giants 2001-2004 | 4 | — |
 Jessie Bates III | Atlanta Falcons 2023-2026 | 4 | — |
 Jordan Addison | Minnesota Vikings 2023-2026 | 4 | — |
 Matt Moore | Carolina Panthers 2007-2010 | 4 | — |
 Nolan Smith Jr. | Philadelphia Eagles 2023-2026 | 4 | — |
| Caleb Farley | Tennessee Titans 2021-2023 | 3 | — |
 Dave Rayner | Cincinnati Bengals 2008, Detroit Lions 2010, Buffalo Bills 2011 | 3 | — |
 DeMario Douglas | New England Patriots 2024, New England Patriots 2025-2026 | 3 | — |
 Drew Lock | Denver Broncos 2019-2021 | 3 | — |
 Garrett Gilbert | Carolina Panthers 2018, Cleveland Browns 2019, Dallas Cowboys 2020 | 3 | — |
 Jake Haener | New Orleans Saints 2023-2025 | 3 | — |
 Jerry Jeudy | Cleveland Browns 2024-2026 | 3 | — |
 Jordan Whitehead | New York Jets 2022-2023, Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2024 | 3 | — |
 Kam Curl | Los Angeles Rams 2024-2026 | 3 | — |
 Mark Sanchez | Philadelphia Eagles 2014-2015, Dallas Cowboys 2016 | 3 | — |
 Nick Novak | Arizona Cardinals 2005, Washington Commanders 2005-2006 | 3 | — |
 Ryan Succop | Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2020-2022 | 3 | — |
 Scott Bentley | Atlanta Falcons 1997, Denver Broncos 1997-2000 | 3 | — |
 Sterling Shepard | New York Giants 2021-2023 | 3 | — |
 Tank Dell | Houston Texans 2023-2025 | 3 | — |
 Tom Savage | Houston Texans 2014-2017 | 3 | — |
 Alex Tanney | New York Giants 2018-2019 | 2 | — |
 Andrew Franks | Miami Dolphins 2015-2016 | 2 | — |
 Austin Seibert | Cincinnati Bengals 2020, Washington Commanders 2024 | 2 | — |
 Brad Nortman | Jacksonville Jaguars 2016-2017 | 2 | — |
 Brandin Cooks | Dallas Cowboys 2023-2024 | 2 | — |
 Cade York | Cleveland Browns 2022, Cincinnati Bengals 2024 | 2 | — |
 Chase McLaughlin | New York Jets 2020, Cleveland Browns 2021 | 2 | — |
 Chidobe Awuzie | Baltimore Ravens 2025-2026 | 2 | — |
 Cody Parkey | Cleveland Browns 2016, Tennessee Titans 2019 | 2 | — |
 Cody Pickett | San Francisco 49ers 2004-2005 | 2 | — |
| D.J. Shockley | Atlanta Falcons 2006-2008 | 2 | — |
| Eddie Murray | Minnesota Vikings 1997, Dallas Cowboys 1999 | 2 | — |
 George Pickens | Dallas Cowboys 2025-2026 | 2 | — |
 Jakobi Meyers | Jacksonville Jaguars 2025-2026 | 2 | — |
| Jeff Chandler | San Francisco 49ers 2002-2003 | 2 | — |
| Jeff Rowe | Cincinnati Bengals 2007, Seattle Seahawks 2008 | 2 | — |
 Jeremy Kapinos | New York Jets 2007, Indianapolis Colts 2010 | 2 | — |
| Josh Rosen | Arizona Cardinals 2018, Miami Dolphins 2019 | 2 | — |
 Kevin Butler | Arizona Cardinals 1996-1997 | 2 | — |
 Matt Flynn | New Orleans Saints 2015-2016 | 2 | — |
 Mike Kafka | Philadelphia Eagles 2010-2011 | 2 | — |
| Mykal Walker | Atlanta Falcons 2021-2022 | 2 | — |
| Nathan Peterman | Las Vegas Raiders 2019-2020 | 2 | — |
 Nick Emmanwori | Seattle Seahawks 2025-2026 | 2 | — |
 Paul Ernster | Denver Broncos 2005-2006 | 2 | — |
 Princely Umanmielen | Carolina Panthers 2025-2026 | 2 | — |
| Raheem Blackshear | Carolina Panthers 2023-2024 | 2 | — |
| Ray-Ray McCloud | San Francisco 49ers 2022-2023 | 2 | — |
 Reggie Hodges | Philadelphia Eagles 2005, Tennessee Titans 2009 | 2 | — |
 Rodrigo Blankenship | Indianapolis Colts 2020-2021 | 2 | — |
| Rohn Stark | Carolina Panthers 1996, Seattle Seahawks 1997 | 2 | — |
 Scott Tolzien | San Francisco 49ers 2011-2012 | 2 | — |
 Shayne Graham | New Orleans Saints 2013-2014 | 2 | — |
 Spencer Shrader | Indianapolis Colts 2025-2026 | 2 | — |
 Stephen Hauschka | Denver Broncos 2010, Jacksonville Jaguars 2020 | 2 | — |
| Tommy Thompson | San Francisco 49ers 1996-1997 | 2 | — |
 Zamir White | Las Vegas Raiders 2024-2025 | 2 | — |
 Abdul Carter | New York Giants 2026 | 1 | — |
 Aldrick Rosas | Tennessee Titans 2016 | 1 | — |
 Anthony Brown | Dallas Cowboys 2022 | 1 | — |
 Anthony Walker Jr. | Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2025 | 1 | — |
| Austin Barnard | Tennessee Titans 2018 | 1 | — |
 Bobby Hebert | Atlanta Falcons 1996 | 1 | — |
 Brad Wing | Pittsburgh Steelers 2023 | 1 | — |
 Brady Quinn | Los Angeles Rams 2013 | 1 | — |
 Brian Hoyer | Pittsburgh Steelers 2012 | 1 | — |
 Brian Robinson Jr. | San Francisco 49ers 2025 | 1 | — |
| Brisly Estime | New York Jets 2017 | 1 | — |
 Brock Berlin | Los Angeles Rams 2007 | 1 | — |
| Byron Pringle | Washington Commanders 2023 | 1 | — |
 Cam Akers | Los Angeles Rams 2022 | 1 | — |
| Cameron Dantzler | Minnesota Vikings 2022 | 1 | — |
 Charlie Frye | Las Vegas Raiders 2009 | 1 | — |
 Chris Johnson | Miami Dolphins 2026 | 1 | — |
 Christian Kirk | San Francisco 49ers 2026 | 1 | — |
 Clint Stitser | Cincinnati Bengals 2010 | 1 | — |
 Colby Wadman | Denver Broncos 2018 | 1 | — |
 Corliss Waitman | Pittsburgh Steelers 2025 | 1 | — |
 David Fales | New York Jets 2019 | 1 | — |
| DeAndre Carter | Las Vegas Raiders 2023 | 1 | — |
 Deonte Banks | New York Giants 2024 | 1 | — |
| Deonte Harty | Baltimore Ravens 2024 | 1 | — |
| Derrick Frost | Cleveland Browns 2003 | 1 | — |
 D.J. Montgomery | Indianapolis Colts 2026 | 1 | — |
| Drew Anderson | Arizona Cardinals 2019 | 1 | — |
| Dwayne Haskins | Pittsburgh Steelers 2021 | 1 | — |
| Edell Shepherd | Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2003 | 1 | — |
 Hunter Smith | Washington Commanders 2009 | 1 | — |
| Jabrill Peppers | New England Patriots 2022 | 1 | — |
| James Proche | Baltimore Ravens 2022 | 1 | — |
 Jaquan Brisker | Pittsburgh Steelers 2026 | 1 | — |
| Jaquiski Tartt | San Francisco 49ers 2021 | 1 | — |
 Jaret Holmes | Jacksonville Jaguars 2001 | 1 | — |
 Jarrett Stidham | Las Vegas Raiders 2022 | 1 | — |
| Jim Cantelupe | Chicago Bears 1999 | 1 | — |
 Joey Slye | Washington Commanders 2021 | 1 | — |
 John Beck | Washington Commanders 2010 | 1 | — |
 John Metchie III | New York Jets 2025 | 1 | — |
 Johnny Hekker | Tennessee Titans 2025 | 1 | — |
 John Potter | Buffalo Bills 2012 | 1 | — |
 Jordan Berry | Minnesota Vikings 2021 | 1 | — |
| Jordan Travis | New York Jets 2024 | 1 | — |
| Joseph Charlton | Carolina Panthers 2020 | 1 | — |
 Josh McCown | Houston Texans 2020 | 1 | — |
 Kai Forbath | Dallas Cowboys 2019 | 1 | — |
 Kamari Lassiter | Houston Texans 2026 | 1 | — |
 Keith Wenning | Cincinnati Bengals 2015 | 1 | — |
 Kene Nwangwu | New York Jets 2026 | 1 | — |
 K.J. Britt | Miami Dolphins 2025 | 1 | — |
 Kliff Kingsbury | New York Jets 2005 | 1 | — |
 Kyle Allen | Houston Texans 2022 | 1 | — |
| Lirim Hajrullahu | Carolina Panthers 2021 | 1 | — |
 L.J. Fort | Baltimore Ravens 2021 | 1 | — |
 Mack Wilson Sr. | New England Patriots 2023 | 1 | — |
| Marquez North | Los Angeles Rams 2016 | 1 | — |
 Marquise Goodwin | Cleveland Browns 2023 | 1 | — |
 Matt Haack | Buffalo Bills 2021 | 1 | — |
| Matt McCrane | Pittsburgh Steelers 2018 | 1 | — |
| Mike White | Dallas Cowboys 2018 | 1 | — |
 Mitch Wishnowsky | San Francisco 49ers 2024 | 1 | — |
| Myles Gaskin | Miami Dolphins 2022 | 1 | — |
 Nate Freese | Detroit Lions 2014 | 1 | — |
| Nick Gallery | New York Jets 1998 | 1 | — |
 Nick Murphy | Philadelphia Eagles 2005 | 1 | — |
| Pat Devlin | Cleveland Browns 2015 | 1 | — |
 Pete Stoyanovich | Los Angeles Rams 2000 | 1 | — |
| Rhett Bomar | Minnesota Vikings 2010 | 1 | — |
 Robbie Chosen | Miami Dolphins 2023 | 1 | — |
| Robert Malone | New York Jets 2012 | 1 | — |
 Rueben Bain Jr. | Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2026 | 1 | — |
| Russell Gage | Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2023 | 1 | — |
 Ryan Lindley | Indianapolis Colts 2015 | 1 | — |
| Sam Hollenbach | Washington Commanders 2007 | 1 | — |
 Shane Andrus | Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2009 | 1 | — |
 Spergon Wynn | Minnesota Vikings 2001 | 1 | — |
| Stefan LeFors | Carolina Panthers 2005 | 1 | — |
 Stefon Diggs | Washington Commanders 2026 | 1 | — |
| Steve Ishmael | Indianapolis Colts 2019 | 1 | — |
 Steven Nelson | Philadelphia Eagles 2021 | 1 | — |
 Steve Weatherford | New York Jets 2015 | 1 | — |
| Tanner Lee | Jacksonville Jaguars 2018 | 1 | — |
| Tarik Black | New York Jets 2021 | 1 | — |
 Taron Johnson | Las Vegas Raiders 2026 | 1 | — |
| Tim Seder | Jacksonville Jaguars 2002 | 1 | — |
| Todd France | Philadelphia Eagles 2005 | 1 | — |
 Tom Brandstater | Denver Broncos 2009 | 1 | — |
 Tommy Townsend | Tennessee Titans 2026 | 1 | — |
 Travis Etienne Jr. | New Orleans Saints 2026 | 1 | — |
 Trevor Siemian | Minnesota Vikings 2018 | 1 | — |
 Tyler Palko | New Orleans Saints 2007 | 1 | — |
 Tyson Campbell | Jacksonville Jaguars 2024 | 1 | — |
| Will Grier | Carolina Panthers 2019 | 1 | — |
| Will Harris | Washington Commanders 2025 | 1 | — |
 William Fuller V | Miami Dolphins 2021 | 1 | — |
 William Jackson III | Pittsburgh Steelers 2022 | 1 | — |
| Zac Dysert | Dallas Cowboys 2017 | 1 | — |
| Zach Pascal | Philadelphia Eagles 2022 | 1 | — |
 Zoltan Mesko | Cincinnati Bengals 2013 | 1 | — |