| George Brett | DH | 1973–1993 | 21 | 3,154 H · 317 HR · 84.0 WAR | Glen Dale, WV |
| Keith Hernandez | 1B | 1974–1990 | 17 | 2,182 H · 162 HR · 57.1 WAR | San Francisco, United States |
| Frank Tanana | SP | 1973–1993 | 21 | 240 W · 2,773 SO · 50.0 WAR | Detroit, MI |
| Jim Rice | DH | 1974–1989 | 16 | 2,452 H · 382 HR · 44.3 WAR | Anderson, SC |
| John Candelaria | RP | 1975–1993 | 19 | 177 W · 1,673 SO · 35.2 WAR | Brooklyn, NY |
| Rick Rhoden | SP | 1974–1989 | 16 | 151 W · 1,419 SO · 27.2 WAR | Boynton Beach, FL |
| Sixto Lezcano | CF | 1974–1985 | 12 | 1,122 H · 148 HR · 25.8 WAR | Arecibo, Puerto Rico |
| Bruce Sutter | RP | 1976–1988 | 12 | 68 W · 861 SO · 23.6 WAR | Lancaster, PA |
| Dan Quisenberry | RP | 1979–1990 | 12 | 56 W · 379 SO · 23.6 WAR | Santa Monica, CA |
| Jim Gantner | 2B | 1976–1992 | 17 | 1,696 H · 47 HR · 19.6 WAR | Fond du Lac, WI |
| Rick Mahler | RP | 1979–1991 | 13 | 96 W · 952 SO · 17.5 WAR | Austin, TX |
| Gene Richards | CF | 1977–1984 | 8 | 1,028 H · 26 HR · 17.4 WAR | Monticello, SC |
| Gary Ward | LF | 1979–1990 | 12 | 1,236 H · 130 HR · 15.9 WAR | Los Angeles, United States |
| Warren Cromartie | 1B | 1974–1991 | 10 | 1,104 H · 61 HR · 14.8 WAR | Miami Beach, FL |
| Tony Armas | RF | 1976–1989 | 14 | 1,302 H · 251 HR · 13.4 WAR | Puerto Piritu, Venezuela |
| Ron Hassey | C | 1978–1991 | 14 | 914 H · 71 HR · 13.3 WAR | Tucson, AZ |
| Larry Herndon | LF | 1974–1988 | 14 | 1,334 H · 107 HR · 13.2 WAR | Sunflower, United States |
| Larry Parrish | 1B | 1974–1988 | 15 | 1,789 H · 256 HR · 12.8 WAR | Winter Haven, United States |
| Rick Camp | RP | 1976–1985 | 9 | 56 W · 407 SO · 12.3 WAR | Trion, United States |
| Larry Andersen | RP | 1975–1994 | 17 | 40 W · 758 SO · 10.5 WAR | Portland, OR |
| Tom Underwood | RP | 1974–1984 | 11 | 86 W · 948 SO · 10.2 WAR | Kokomo, IN |
| Bo Diaz | C | 1977–1989 | 13 | 834 H · 87 HR · 10.1 WAR | Cua, Venezuela |
| Tom Brookens | 3B | 1979–1990 | 12 | 950 H · 71 HR · 9.9 WAR | Chambersburg, United States |
| Ivan DeJesus | SS | 1974–1988 | 15 | 1,167 H · 21 HR · 9.5 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
| Roy Howell | 3B | 1974–1984 | 11 | 991 H · 80 HR · 9.1 WAR | Lompoc, United States |
| Pete Falcone | RP | 1975–1984 | 10 | 70 W · 865 SO · 8.7 WAR | Brooklyn, NY |
| Charlie Moore | C | 1973–1987 | 15 | 1,052 H · 36 HR · 8.5 WAR | Birmingham, United States |
| U.L. Washington | SS | 1977–1987 | 11 | 703 H · 27 HR · 7.9 WAR | Stringtown, OK |
| Larry Christenson | SP | 1973–1983 | 11 | 83 W · 781 SO · 7.6 WAR | Everett, WA |
| Francisco Barrios | SP | 1974–1981 | 7 | 38 W · 323 SO · 7.6 WAR | Hermosillo, Mexico |
| Rob Wilfong | 2B | 1977–1987 | 11 | 668 H · 39 HR · 6.3 WAR | Pasadena, United States |
| Mark Littell | RP | 1973–1982 | 9 | 32 W · 466 SO · 6.2 WAR | Cape Girardeau, MO |
| Ron Jackson | 1B | 1975–1984 | 10 | 774 H · 56 HR · 5.8 WAR | Birmingham, United States |
| Dave Bergman | 1B | 1975–1992 | 17 | 690 H · 54 HR · 5.5 WAR | Evanston, United States |
| Paul Hartzell | RP | 1976–1984 | 6 | 27 W · 237 SO · 5.3 WAR | Bloomsburg, United States |
| Tom Hume | RP | 1977–1987 | 11 | 57 W · 536 SO · 5.1 WAR | Cincinnati, OH |
| Terry Whitfield | CF | 1974–1986 | 9 | 537 H · 33 HR · 5.0 WAR | Blythe, United States |
| Bob Lacey | RP | 1977–1984 | 7 | 20 W · 251 SO · 4.2 WAR | Fredericksburg, VA |
| Dave Revering | 1B | 1978–1982 | 5 | 486 H · 62 HR · 4.2 WAR | Roseville, United States |
| Kiko Garcia | SS | 1976–1985 | 10 | 351 H · 12 HR · 4.1 WAR | Martinez, United States |
| Luis Aponte | RP | 1980–1984 | 5 | 9 W · 113 SO · 4.1 WAR | El Tigre, Venezuela |
| Luis Sanchez | RP | 1981–1985 | 5 | 28 W · 216 SO · 3.6 WAR | Cariaco, Venezuela |
| Tim Stoddard | RP | 1975–1989 | 13 | 41 W · 582 SO · 3.5 WAR | East Chicago, IN |
| Nino Espinosa | SP | 1974–1981 | 8 | 44 W · 338 SO · 3.5 WAR | Villa Altagracia, Dominican Republic |
| Rodney Scott | 2B | 1975–1982 | 8 | 504 H · 3 HR · 3.0 WAR | Indianapolis, IN |
| Dave Tobik | RP | 1978–1985 | 8 | 14 W · 256 SO · 2.9 WAR | Euclid, OH |
| Tom Hausman | RP | 1975–1982 | 7 | 15 W · 180 SO · 2.8 WAR | Mobridge, SD |
| Roy Thomas | RP | 1977–1987 | 8 | 20 W · 289 SO · 2.7 WAR | Quantico, VA |
| Jim Umbarger | P | 1975–1978 | 4 | 25 W · 244 SO · 2.6 WAR | — |
| Billy Smith | SS | 1975–1981 | 6 | 234 H · 17 HR · 2.4 WAR | Hodge, LA |
| Paul Moskau | SP | 1977–1983 | 7 | 32 W · 374 SO · 2.2 WAR | St. Joseph, MO |
| Larry Demery | P | 1974–1977 | 4 | 29 W · 217 SO · 2.0 WAR | — |
| Kevin Kobel | RP | 1973–1980 | 6 | 18 W · 205 SO · 1.9 WAR | Buffalo, NY |
| Rick Matula | RP | 1979–1981 | 3 | 19 W · 129 SO · 1.7 WAR | Wharton, United States |
| Rick Bosetti | CF | 1976–1982 | 7 | 385 H · 17 HR · 1.6 WAR | Redding, United States |
| Mark Bomback | SP | 1978–1982 | 4 | 16 W · 124 SO · 1.6 WAR | Portsmouth, VA |
| Mike Paxton | RP | 1977–1980 | 4 | 30 W · 230 SO · 1.5 WAR | Memphis, United States |
| Jose Baez | — | 1977–1978 | 2 | 87 H · 1 HR · 1.4 WAR | — |
| Al Woods | DH | 1977–1986 | 7 | 538 H · 35 HR · 1.0 WAR | Oakland, United States |
| Ed Glynn | RP | 1975–1985 | 10 | 12 W · 184 SO · 0.9 WAR | New York, NY |
| Juan Eichelberger | RP | 1978–1988 | 7 | 26 W · 281 SO · 0.7 WAR | St. Louis, MO |
| Rick Baldwin | P | 1975–1977 | 3 | 4 W · 86 SO · 0.7 WAR | — |
| Odell Jones | RP | 1975–1988 | 9 | 24 W · 338 SO · 0.6 WAR | Tulare, United States |
| Tom Bruno | P | 1976–1979 | 4 | 7 W · 80 SO · 0.6 WAR | — |
| Mike Rowland | RP | 1980–1981 | 2 | 1 W · 16 SO · 0.6 WAR | Chicago, United States |
| Barry Bonnell | 1B | 1977–1986 | 10 | 833 H · 56 HR · 0.5 WAR | Mariemont, OH |
| Tim Corcoran | 1B | 1977–1986 | 9 | 283 H · 12 HR · 0.5 WAR | Glendale, CA |
| Phil Mankowski | 3B | 1976–1982 | 6 | 195 H · 8 HR · 0.5 WAR | Buffalo, NY |
| Larry Wolfe | 3B | 1977–1980 | 4 | 83 H · 7 HR · 0.5 WAR | Melbourne, United States |
| Bruce Taylor | P | 1977–1979 | 3 | 2 W · 27 SO · 0.5 WAR | — |
| Mark Lee | RP | 1978–1981 | 4 | 7 W · 63 SO · 0.4 WAR | Inglewood, United States |
| Andy Replogle | P | 1978–1979 | 2 | 9 W · 43 SO · 0.4 WAR | — |
| Bobby Thompson | — | 1978 | 1 | 27 H · 2 HR · 0.4 WAR | — |
| Rafael Landestoy | 2B | 1977–1984 | 8 | 291 H · 4 HR · 0.2 WAR | Bani, Dominican Republic |
| Keith Smith | CF | 1977–1980 | 3 | 23 H · 2 HR · 0.2 WAR | Palmetto, United States |
| Gary Alexander | 1B | 1975–1981 | 7 | 293 H · 55 HR · 0.1 WAR | Los Angeles, United States |
| Paul Siebert | P | 1974–1978 | 5 | 3 W · 59 SO · 0.1 WAR | — |
| Gene Pentz | P | 1975–1978 | 4 | 8 W · 116 SO · 0.1 WAR | — |
| Dave Schuler | RP | 1979–1985 | 3 | 0 W · 17 SO · 0.1 WAR | Framingham, MA |
| Paul Thormodsgard | P | 1977–1979 | 3 | 12 W · 118 SO · 0.1 WAR | — |
| Rick Anderson | P | 1979–1980 | 2 | 0 W · 7 SO · 0.1 WAR | — |
| Kim Andrew | — | 1975 | 1 | 1 H · 0 HR · 0.1 WAR | — |
| Roger Slagle | P | 1979 | 1 | 0 W · 2 SO · 0.1 WAR | — |
| Ed Putman | — | 1976–1979 | 3 | 17 H · 2 HR | — |
| Frank Riccelli | P | 1976–1979 | 3 | 3 W · 32 SO | — |
| Brock Pemberton | — | 1974–1975 | 2 | 4 H · 0 HR | — |
| Duane Theiss | P | 1977–1978 | 2 | 1 W · 10 SO | — |
| Jerry Maddox | — | 1978 | 1 | 3 H · 0 HR | — |
| Jesus de la Rosa | — | 1975 | 1 | 1 H · 0 HR | — |
| Mark DeJohn | SS | 1982 | 1 | 4 H · 0 HR | Middletown, CT |
| Mark Williams | — | 1977 | 1 | 0 H · 0 HR | — |
| Steve Davis | — | 1979 | 1 | 0 H · 0 HR | — |
| Bob Pate | CF | 1980–1981 | 2 | 12 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | Los Angeles, United States |
| Kim Allen | 2B | 1980–1981 | 2 | 12 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | Fontana, United States |
| Mike Sember | — | 1977–1978 | 2 | 2 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Taylor Duncan | — | 1977–1978 | 2 | 86 H · 3 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Tim Ireland | 2B | 1981–1982 | 2 | 1 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | Oakland, CA |
| Dennis Debarr | P | 1977 | 1 | 0 W · 10 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Hank Small | — | 1978 | 1 | 0 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Sam Hinds | P | 1977 | 1 | 0 W · 46 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |