| Brian Downing | DH | 1973–1992 | 20 | 2,099 H · 275 HR · 47.8 WAR | Los Angeles, United States |
| Ron Guidry | SP | 1975–1988 | 14 | 170 W · 1,778 SO · 45.4 WAR | Lafayette, LA |
| Doug DeCinces | 3B | 1973–1987 | 15 | 1,505 H · 237 HR · 38.6 WAR | Burbank, United States |
| Jon Matlack | RP | 1971–1983 | 13 | 125 W · 1,516 SO · 36.3 WAR | West Chester, PA |
| Burt Hooton | SP | 1971–1985 | 15 | 151 W · 1,491 SO · 34.4 WAR | Greenville, United States |
| Ken Griffey Sr. | LF | 1973–1991 | 19 | 2,143 H · 152 HR · 31.6 WAR | Donora, PA |
| Frank White | 2B | 1973–1990 | 18 | 2,006 H · 160 HR · 31.1 WAR | Greenville, MS |
Chris Speier | SS | 1971–1989 | 19 | 1,759 H · 112 HR · 27.9 WAR | Alameda, CA |
| Gary Matthews | DH | 1972–1987 | 16 | 2,011 H · 234 HR · 27.3 WAR | San Fernando, CA |
| Doyle Alexander | SP | 1971–1989 | 19 | 194 W · 1,528 SO · 26.9 WAR | Cordova, AL |
| Greg Luzinski | DH | 1970–1984 | 15 | 1,795 H · 307 HR · 23.6 WAR | Chicago, United States |
| J.R. Richard | SP | 1971–1980 | 10 | 107 W · 1,493 SO · 19.9 WAR | Vienna, LA |
| John Montefusco | RP | 1974–1986 | 13 | 90 W · 1,081 SO · 18.8 WAR | Long Branch, NJ |
| Gorman Thomas | DH | 1973–1986 | 13 | 1,051 H · 268 HR · 17.2 WAR | Charleston, SC |
| Randy Jones | SP | 1973–1982 | 10 | 100 W · 735 SO · 16.8 WAR | Fullerton, United States |
| Bob Forsch | RP | 1974–1989 | 16 | 168 W · 1,133 SO · 16.7 WAR | Sacramento, United States |
| Bruce Bochte | 1B | 1974–1986 | 12 | 1,478 H · 100 HR · 16.7 WAR | Pasadena, United States |
| Jim Slaton | RP | 1971–1986 | 16 | 151 W · 1,191 SO · 15.6 WAR | Long Beach, United States |
| Milt May | C | 1970–1984 | 15 | 971 H · 77 HR · 14.8 WAR | Gary, IN |
| Ray Burris | RP | 1973–1987 | 15 | 108 W · 1,065 SO · 12.9 WAR | Idabel, OK |
| Bruce Kison | RP | 1971–1985 | 15 | 115 W · 1,073 SO · 12.5 WAR | Pasco, WA |
| Lyman Bostock | — | 1975–1978 | 4 | 624 H · 23 HR · 12.1 WAR | — |
| Jorge Orta | DH | 1972–1987 | 16 | 1,619 H · 130 HR · 11.9 WAR | Mazatlan, Mexico |
| Craig Swan | RP | 1973–1984 | 12 | 59 W · 673 SO · 11.5 WAR | Van Nuys, United States |
| Mike Easler | DH | 1973–1987 | 14 | 1,078 H · 118 HR · 11.2 WAR | Cleveland, OH |
| Lynn McGlothen | RP | 1972–1982 | 11 | 86 W · 939 SO · 11.1 WAR | Monroe, LA |
| Ed Halicki | RP | 1974–1980 | 7 | 55 W · 707 SO · 10.8 WAR | Kearny, NJ |
| Milt Wilcox | SP | 1970–1986 | 16 | 119 W · 1,137 SO · 10.7 WAR | Honolulu, HI |
| Elias Sosa | RP | 1972–1983 | 12 | 59 W · 538 SO · 9.4 WAR | La Vega, Dominican Republic |
| Otto Velez | DH | 1973–1983 | 11 | 452 H · 78 HR · 9.0 WAR | Ponce, Puerto Rico |
| Manny Trillo | 2B | 1973–1989 | 17 | 1,562 H · 61 HR · 8.4 WAR | Caripito, Venezuela |
| Bart Johnson | P | 1969–1977 | 8 | 43 W · 520 SO · 8.2 WAR | — |
| Mike Proly | RP | 1976–1983 | 7 | 22 W · 185 SO · 7.6 WAR | Jamaica, NY |
| Juan Beniquez | LF | 1971–1988 | 17 | 1,274 H · 79 HR · 7.5 WAR | San Sebastian, Puerto Rico |
| Dave Heaverlo | RP | 1975–1981 | 7 | 26 W · 288 SO · 6.8 WAR | Ellensburg, WA |
| Dave Chalk | 3B | 1973–1981 | 9 | 733 H · 15 HR · 6.6 WAR | Del Rio, United States |
| Tippy Martinez | RP | 1974–1988 | 14 | 55 W · 632 SO · 6.4 WAR | La Junta, CO |
| Doug Bird | RP | 1973–1983 | 11 | 73 W · 680 SO · 6.3 WAR | Corona, CA |
| Wayne Garland | SP | 1973–1981 | 9 | 55 W · 450 SO · 6.3 WAR | Nashville, United States |
| Ross Grimsley | RP | 1971–1982 | 11 | 124 W · 750 SO · 5.6 WAR | Topeka, KS |
| Mike Cubbage | 3B | 1974–1981 | 8 | 503 H · 34 HR · 5.5 WAR | Charlottesville, VA |
| Bob Apodaca | P | 1973–1977 | 5 | 16 W · 197 SO · 5.0 WAR | — |
| Jim Dwyer | DH | 1973–1990 | 18 | 719 H · 77 HR · 4.8 WAR | Evergreen Park, IL |
| Glenn Borgmann | C | 1972–1980 | 9 | 296 H · 16 HR · 4.8 WAR | Paterson, NJ |
| Lamar Johnson | DH | 1974–1982 | 9 | 755 H · 64 HR · 4.4 WAR | Bessemer, United States |
| Jack Brohamer | 2B | 1972–1980 | 9 | 613 H · 30 HR · 4.0 WAR | Maywood, United States |
| Tim Foli | SS | 1970–1985 | 16 | 1,515 H · 25 HR · 3.4 WAR | Culver City, CA |
| Max Leon | P | 1973–1978 | 6 | 14 W · 170 SO · 3.2 WAR | — |
| Rawly Eastwick | RP | 1974–1981 | 8 | 28 W · 295 SO · 3.0 WAR | Camden, NJ |
| Dave Lemanczyk | RP | 1973–1980 | 8 | 37 W · 429 SO · 2.8 WAR | Syracuse, NY |
| Rich Coggins | — | 1972–1976 | 5 | 287 H · 12 HR · 2.7 WAR | — |
| Duane Kuiper | 2B | 1974–1985 | 12 | 917 H · 1 HR · 2.6 WAR | Racine, United States |
| Junior Kennedy | 2B | 1974–1983 | 7 | 258 H · 4 HR · 2.3 WAR | Fort Gibson, OK |
| Jim Wright | P | 1978–1979 | 2 | 9 W · 71 SO · 2.3 WAR | — |
| Dale Murray | RP | 1974–1985 | 12 | 53 W · 400 SO · 2.2 WAR | Cuero, United States |
| Larvell Blanks | SS | 1972–1980 | 9 | 446 H · 20 HR · 2.2 WAR | Del Rio, United States |
| Roy Staiger | — | 1975–1979 | 4 | 104 H · 4 HR · 2.1 WAR | — |
| Bill Fahey | C | 1971–1983 | 11 | 225 H · 7 HR · 1.6 WAR | Detroit, MI |
| Bill Sharp | — | 1973–1976 | 4 | 281 H · 9 HR · 1.3 WAR | — |
| Bobby Valentine | — | 1969–1979 | 10 | 441 H · 12 HR · 1.2 WAR | — |
| Jeff Terpko | P | 1974–1977 | 3 | 3 W · 41 SO · 1.2 WAR | — |
| Mike Willis | RP | 1977–1981 | 5 | 7 W · 149 SO · 1.1 WAR | Oklahoma City, OK |
| Mike Beard | P | 1974–1977 | 4 | 4 W · 43 SO · 1.1 WAR | — |
| Buddy Schultz | P | 1975–1979 | 5 | 15 W · 193 SO · 0.9 WAR | — |
| Dick Sharon | — | 1973–1975 | 3 | 102 H · 13 HR · 0.5 WAR | — |
| Bob Molinaro | DH | 1975–1983 | 8 | 212 H · 14 HR · 0.4 WAR | Newark, NJ |
| George Zeber | — | 1977–1978 | 2 | 21 H · 3 HR · 0.3 WAR | — |
| Rick Auerbach | SS | 1971–1981 | 11 | 309 H · 9 HR · 0.2 WAR | Woodland Hills, CA |
| Bob Sheldon | — | 1974–1977 | 3 | 67 H · 0 HR · 0.2 WAR | — |
| Pat Darcy | P | 1974–1976 | 3 | 14 W · 75 SO · 0.2 WAR | — |
| Steve Lawson | P | 1972 | 1 | 0 W · 13 SO · 0.2 WAR | — |
| Mike Phillips | SS | 1973–1983 | 11 | 412 H · 11 HR · 0.1 WAR | Beaumont, TX |
| Andy Merchant | — | 1975–1976 | 2 | 2 H · 0 HR · 0.1 WAR | — |
| John Fuller | — | 1974 | 1 | 1 H · 0 HR · 0.1 WAR | — |
| Dane Iorg | 1B | 1977–1986 | 10 | 455 H · 14 HR | Eureka, United States |
| Rich Troedson | P | 1973–1974 | 2 | 8 W · 92 SO | — |
| Bill Moran | P | 1974 | 1 | 1 W · 17 SO | — |
| Bob Kaiser | P | 1971 | 1 | 0 W · 4 SO | — |
| Greg Harts | — | 1973 | 1 | 1 H · 0 HR | — |
| Larry Yount | P | 1971 | 1 | 0 W · 0 SO | — |
| Richie Moloney | P | 1970 | 1 | 0 W · 1 SO | — |
| Mike McQueen | P | 1969–1974 | 5 | 5 W · 140 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |
| George Throop | P | 1975–1979 | 4 | 2 W · 27 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Jim Fuller | — | 1973–1977 | 3 | 61 H · 11 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Butch Alberts | — | 1978 | 1 | 5 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Clint Compton | P | 1972 | 1 | 0 W · 0 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Don Castle | — | 1973 | 1 | 4 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Tom Norton | P | 1972 | 1 | 0 W · 22 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Larry Johnson | — | 1972–1978 | 5 | 5 H · 0 HR · -0.2 WAR | — |
| Doug Ault | 1B | 1976–1980 | 4 | 168 H · 17 HR · -0.2 WAR | Beaumont, TX |
| Rudy Arroyo | P | 1971 | 1 | 0 W · 5 SO · -0.2 WAR | — |
| Terry Enyart | P | 1974 | 1 | 0 W · 2 SO · -0.2 WAR | — |
| Tommy Sandt | — | 1976 | 1 | 14 H · 0 HR · -0.2 WAR | — |
| Marvin Lane | — | 1971–1976 | 5 | 37 H · 3 HR · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Bob Kammeyer | P | 1978–1979 | 2 | 0 W · 11 SO · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Jack Baker | — | 1976–1977 | 2 | 3 H · 1 HR · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Bob Strampe | P | 1972 | 1 | 0 W · 4 SO · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Dave Coleman | — | 1977 | 1 | 0 H · 0 HR · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Joe Goddard | — | 1972 | 1 | 7 H · 0 HR · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Tom Makowski | P | 1975 | 1 | 0 W · 3 SO · -0.3 WAR | — |