| Mike Schmidt | 3B | 1972–1989 | 18 | 2,234 H · 548 HR · 103.0 WAR | Dayton, OH |
| Bobby Grich | 2B | 1970–1986 | 17 | 1,833 H · 224 HR · 67.3 WAR | Muskegon, MI |
| Rick Reuschel | RP | 1972–1991 | 19 | 214 W · 2,015 SO · 59.3 WAR | Quincy, United States |
| Ted Simmons | 1B | 1968–1988 | 21 | 2,472 H · 248 HR · 46.7 WAR | Highland Park, United States |
| Steve Rogers | SP | 1973–1985 | 13 | 158 W · 1,621 SO · 42.2 WAR | Jefferson City, MO |
| Vida Blue | SP | 1969–1986 | 17 | 209 W · 2,175 SO · 41.3 WAR | Mansfield, LA |
| Garry Maddox | CF | 1972–1986 | 15 | 1,802 H · 117 HR · 34.4 WAR | Cincinnati, OH |
Dusty Baker | DH | 1968–1986 | 19 | 1,981 H · 242 HR · 34.2 WAR | Riverside, United States |
| Cecil Cooper | DH | 1971–1987 | 17 | 2,192 H · 241 HR · 32.6 WAR | Brenham, United States |
| Jerry Reuss | RP | 1969–1990 | 22 | 220 W · 1,907 SO · 30.9 WAR | St. Louis, MO |
| Mike Hargrove | 1B | 1974–1985 | 12 | 1,614 H · 80 HR · 27.4 WAR | Perryton, United States |
| Phil Garner | 3B | 1973–1988 | 16 | 1,594 H · 109 HR · 26.5 WAR | Jefferson City, United States |
| George Hendrick | LF | 1971–1988 | 18 | 1,980 H · 267 HR · 25.6 WAR | Los Angeles, United States |
| Don Baylor | DH | 1970–1988 | 19 | 2,135 H · 338 HR · 24.4 WAR | Austin, United States |
| Ben Oglivie | DH | 1971–1986 | 16 | 1,615 H · 235 HR · 23.4 WAR | Colon, Panama |
| Rick Dempsey | C | 1969–1992 | 24 | 1,093 H · 96 HR · 23.1 WAR | Fayetteville, United States |
| Richie Zisk | DH | 1971–1983 | 13 | 1,477 H · 207 HR · 23.1 WAR | Brooklyn, NY |
| Andre Thornton | DH | 1973–1987 | 14 | 1,342 H · 253 HR · 22.0 WAR | Tuskegee, United States |
| John Mayberry | 1B | 1968–1982 | 15 | 1,379 H · 255 HR · 21.5 WAR | Detroit, United States |
| Bake McBride | DH | 1973–1983 | 11 | 1,153 H · 63 HR · 21.2 WAR | Fulton, MO |
| Dave Goltz | RP | 1972–1983 | 12 | 113 W · 1,105 SO · 20.6 WAR | Pelican Rapids, MN |
| Oscar Gamble | DH | 1969–1985 | 17 | 1,195 H · 200 HR · 20.5 WAR | Ramer, United States |
| Gary Lavelle | RP | 1974–1987 | 13 | 80 W · 769 SO · 18.9 WAR | Scranton, United States |
| Mike Caldwell | SP | 1971–1984 | 14 | 137 W · 939 SO · 16.3 WAR | Tarboro, United States |
| Steve Busby | SP | 1972–1980 | 8 | 70 W · 659 SO · 15.1 WAR | Burbank, CA |
| Jim Kern | RP | 1974–1986 | 13 | 53 W · 651 SO · 12.9 WAR | Gladwin, United States |
| Bill Buckner | 1B | 1969–1990 | 22 | 2,715 H · 174 HR · 11.8 WAR | Vallejo, United States |
| John Milner | 1B | 1971–1982 | 12 | 855 H · 131 HR · 11.1 WAR | Atlanta, GA |
| Lenny Randle | DH | 1971–1982 | 12 | 1,016 H · 27 HR · 9.7 WAR | Long Beach, United States |
| Al Hrabosky | RP | 1970–1982 | 13 | 64 W · 548 SO · 9.4 WAR | Oakland, United States |
| Enos Cabell | 1B | 1972–1986 | 15 | 1,647 H · 60 HR · 9.0 WAR | Fort Riley, KS |
| Doug Bair | RP | 1976–1990 | 15 | 55 W · 689 SO · 8.4 WAR | Defiance, OH |
| Roger Moret | P | 1970–1978 | 9 | 47 W · 408 SO · 6.5 WAR | — |
| John Wockenfuss | 1B | 1974–1985 | 12 | 543 H · 86 HR · 6.3 WAR | Welch, WV |
| Ron Hodges | C | 1973–1984 | 12 | 342 H · 19 HR · 5.7 WAR | Rocky Mount, VA |
| Steve Foucault | P | 1973–1978 | 6 | 35 W · 307 SO · 4.9 WAR | — |
| Steve Brye | — | 1970–1978 | 9 | 515 H · 30 HR · 4.4 WAR | — |
| Greg Pryor | 3B | 1976–1986 | 10 | 471 H · 14 HR · 3.8 WAR | Marietta, OH |
| John Wathan | C | 1976–1985 | 10 | 656 H · 21 HR · 3.7 WAR | Cedar Rapids, IA |
| Don Hood | RP | 1973–1983 | 10 | 34 W · 374 SO · 3.5 WAR | Florence, SC |
| Jim Willoughby | P | 1971–1978 | 8 | 26 W · 250 SO · 3.4 WAR | — |
| Larry Lintz | — | 1973–1978 | 6 | 140 H · 0 HR · 2.5 WAR | — |
| Paul Mitchell | SP | 1975–1980 | 6 | 32 W · 277 SO · 2.4 WAR | Worcester, MA |
| Mike Garman | P | 1969–1978 | 9 | 22 W · 213 SO · 2.2 WAR | — |
| Ray Corbin | P | 1971–1975 | 5 | 36 W · 348 SO · 2.1 WAR | — |
| Stan Thomas | P | 1974–1977 | 4 | 11 W · 123 SO · 2.1 WAR | — |
| Larry Bradford | RP | 1977–1981 | 4 | 6 W · 58 SO · 1.4 WAR | Chicago, IL |
| Gene Locklear | — | 1973–1977 | 5 | 163 H · 9 HR · 1.3 WAR | — |
| Jerry Martin | 1B | 1974–1984 | 11 | 666 H · 85 HR · 1.2 WAR | Columbia, SC |
| Steve Dunning | P | 1970–1977 | 7 | 23 W · 390 SO · 1.0 WAR | — |
| Mac Scarce | P | 1972–1978 | 5 | 6 W · 164 SO · 1.0 WAR | — |
| Chico Escarrega | RP | 1982 | 1 | 1 W · 33 SO · 0.9 WAR | Los Mochis, Mexico |
| Frank Taveras | SS | 1972–1982 | 10 | 1,029 H · 2 HR · 0.4 WAR | Las Matas de Santa Cruz, Dominican Republic |
| Dennis Saunders | P | 1970 | 1 | 1 W · 8 SO · 0.4 WAR | — |
| Greg Thayer | P | 1978 | 1 | 1 W · 30 SO · 0.4 WAR | — |
| Bob Babcock | RP | 1979–1981 | 3 | 2 W · 39 SO · 0.3 WAR | New Castle, United States |
| Ron Cash | — | 1973–1974 | 2 | 30 H · 0 HR · 0.3 WAR | — |
| Herb Hutson | P | 1974 | 1 | 0 W · 22 SO · 0.3 WAR | — |
| Dennis O'toole | P | 1969–1973 | 5 | 0 W · 22 SO · 0.2 WAR | — |
| Santiago Guzman | P | 1969–1972 | 4 | 1 W · 29 SO · 0.2 WAR | — |
| Bob O'brien | P | 1971 | 1 | 2 W · 15 SO · 0.2 WAR | — |
| Reggie Sanders | — | 1974 | 1 | 27 H · 3 HR · 0.2 WAR | — |
| Fred Kendall | C | 1969–1980 | 12 | 603 H · 31 HR · 0.1 WAR | Torrance, United States |
| Pete Varney | — | 1973–1976 | 4 | 47 H · 5 HR · 0.1 WAR | — |
| Tom Brown | P | 1978 | 1 | 0 W · 8 SO · 0.1 WAR | — |
| Jim Tyrone | — | 1972–1977 | 4 | 92 H · 8 HR | — |
| Hugh Yancy | — | 1972–1976 | 3 | 2 H · 0 HR | — |
| Jim Geddes | P | 1972–1973 | 2 | 0 W · 10 SO | — |
| Skip James | — | 1977–1978 | 2 | 6 H · 0 HR | — |
| Frank Snook | P | 1973 | 1 | 0 W · 13 SO | — |
| Gary Ignasiak | P | 1973 | 1 | 0 W · 4 SO | — |
| Ike Brookens | P | 1975 | 1 | 0 W · 8 SO | — |
| Jay Kleven | — | 1976 | 1 | 1 H · 0 HR | — |
| Jay Schlueter | — | 1971 | 1 | 1 H · 0 HR | — |
| Jim Deidel | — | 1974 | 1 | 0 H · 0 HR | — |
| John Young | — | 1971 | 1 | 2 H · 0 HR | — |
| Larry Fritz | — | 1975 | 1 | 0 H · 0 HR | — |
| Mike Buskey | — | 1977 | 1 | 2 H · 0 HR | — |
| Terry Cox | P | 1970 | 1 | 0 W · 3 SO | — |
| Rich Chiles | — | 1971–1978 | 6 | 157 H · 6 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Brian Ostrosser | — | 1973 | 1 | 0 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Ike Blessitt | — | 1972 | 1 | 0 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Jimmy McMath | — | 1968 | 1 | 2 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Jim Obradovich | — | 1978 | 1 | 3 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| John Andrews | P | 1973 | 1 | 1 W · 5 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Juan Jimenez | P | 1974 | 1 | 0 W · 2 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Mike Reinbach | — | 1974 | 1 | 5 H · 0 HR · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Ramon Delos santos | P | 1974 | 1 | 1 W · 7 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Roger Hambright | P | 1971 | 1 | 3 W · 14 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Terry Wilshusen | P | 1973 | 1 | 0 W · 0 SO · -0.1 WAR | — |
| Terry Hughes | — | 1970–1974 | 3 | 18 H · 1 HR · -0.2 WAR | — |
| Danny Fife | P | 1973–1974 | 2 | 3 W · 21 SO · -0.2 WAR | — |
| Mark Ballinger | P | 1971 | 1 | 1 W · 25 SO · -0.2 WAR | — |
| Paul Jata | — | 1972 | 1 | 17 H · 0 HR · -0.2 WAR | — |
| Tim Nordbrook | — | 1974–1979 | 6 | 30 H · 0 HR · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Don Kirkwood | P | 1974–1978 | 5 | 18 W · 194 SO · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Dave Augustine | — | 1973–1974 | 2 | 6 H · 0 HR · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Bob Rauch | P | 1972 | 1 | 0 W · 23 SO · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Bruce Ellingsen | P | 1974 | 1 | 1 W · 16 SO · -0.3 WAR | — |
| Ray Bare | P | 1972–1977 | 5 | 16 W · 145 SO · -0.4 WAR | — |