Arnie Herber vs Sid Luckman

0of 3 lines

3of 3 lines

Arnie Herber and Sid Luckman compared on their NFL careers: Arnie Herber played 13 seasons, 1930 to 1945, Sid Luckman 12 seasons, 1939 to 1950. Arnie Herber has 8,324 passing yards to Sid Luckman's 14,686.

Who has the better career numbers?

Sid Luckman leads in 3 of the 3 lines, Arnie Herber in 0. Bold marks the better figure; playing time — games, minutes, at-bats, innings — is not scored.

Arnie Herber and Sid Luckman career totals
129GP128
8,324YDS14,686, better
81TD137, better
6.8AVG8.4, better

How do they compare in the playoffs?

Arnie Herber and Sid Luckman postseason
4GP6
431YDS721, better
4TD7, better
7.4AVG8.5, better

Where each stands all time

Arnie Herber and Sid Luckman all-time places
186th (8,324)Passing yards146th (14,686), better
145th (81)Passing touchdowns91st (137), better

Among the NFL players with a career line on file, regular season, counting stats only — the same lists the records pages run on.

Titles and awards

Neither has a championship or an award on file.

Awards come from the league’s published winner lists; a championship counts a season played for the club that won it.

Season by season

Lined up by career year, not by calendar: each row is the players’ nth season.

Arnie Herber and Sid Luckman season by season
YDS: Yards gained through the air, on the ground or after a catch, whichever this table counts.TD: Touchdowns, worth six points before the extra point.INT: Interceptions — thrown away by a quarterback, taken by a defender.YDS: Yards gained through the air, on the ground or after a catch, whichever this table counts.TD: Touchdowns, worth six points before the extra point.INT: Interceptions — thrown away by a quarterback, taken by a defender.
1st193020533, better1939636, better5, better4
2nd19317800, better1940941, better4, better9
3rd19326399919411,181, better96, better
4th1933656312, better19421,024, better10, better13
5th193479981219432,194, better28, better12
6th193572981419441,018, better11, better12, better
7th19361,239111319451,727, better14, better10, better
8th1937684710, better19461,826, better17, better16
9th193833634, better19472,712, better24, better31
10th19391,107, better89, better19481,04713, better14
11th1940560, better6, better7194920013, better
12th1944651, better6, better8195018012, better
13th194564198————

What the columns mean: INT