Players who played for the Cleveland Guardians and St. Louis Cardinals

Cleveland Guardians
St. Louis Cardinals

120 players

120 players have played for both the Cleveland Guardians and the St. Louis Cardinals. Jake Westbrook spent the most seasons with the two: 9 with the Cleveland Guardians and 4 with the St. Louis Cardinals. On a roster now: Shawn Armstrong, Lane Thomas, and Richie Palacios. Every season since 1876 is on file.

Players who played for the Cleveland Guardians and the St. Louis Cardinals, with their years at each
PlayerPosCLESTL
Jake WestbrookSP2001–2010 · 9 seasons2010–2013 · 4 seasons
Jhonny Peralta3B2003–2010 · 8 seasons2014–2017 · 4 seasons
Keith Hernandez1B1990 · 1 season1974–1982 · 9 seasons
George HendrickLF1973–1976 · 4 seasons1979–1984 · 6 seasons
Einar DiazC1996–2002 · 7 seasons2005 · 1 season
John DennySP1980–1981 · 2 seasons1974–1979 · 6 seasons
Tito Francona—1959–1964 · 6 seasons1965–1966 · 2 seasons
Ted WilksP1953 · 1 season1944–1950 · 7 seasons
Marc RzepczynskiRP2013–2018 · 4 seasons2011–2013 · 3 seasons
Justin MastersonSP2009–2014 · 6 seasons2014 · 1 season
Chris PerezRP2009–2013 · 5 seasons2008–2009 · 2 seasons
Ryan LudwickLF2003–2005 · 3 seasons2007–2010 · 4 seasons
Geronimo Pena3B1996 · 1 season1990–1995 · 6 seasons
Jim LindseyP1922–1924 · 2 seasons1929–1933 · 5 seasons
Andrew MillerRP2016–2018 · 3 seasons2019–2021 · 3 seasons
Russell Branyan1B1998–2010 · 5 seasons2007 · 1 season
Anthony ReyesRP2008–2009 · 2 seasons2005–2008 · 4 seasons
Julian TavarezRP1993–1996 · 4 seasons2004–2005 · 2 seasons
Mark WhitenCF1992–2000 · 4 seasons1993–1994 · 2 seasons
Bake McBrideDH1982–1983 · 2 seasons1973–1976 · 4 seasons
Sonny SiebertP1964–1968 · 5 seasons1974 · 1 season
Vic Davalillo1B1963–1967 · 5 seasons1970 · 1 season
Fred Whitfield—1963–1967 · 5 seasons1962 · 1 season
Johnny Romano—1960–1964 · 5 seasons1967 · 1 season
Shawn ArmstrongRP2015–2026 · 4 seasons2024 · 1 season
Edward MujicaRP2006–2008 · 3 seasons2012–2013 · 2 seasons
Eduardo PérezDH2006 · 1 season1999–2003 · 4 seasons
Dennis EckersleyRP1975–1977 · 3 seasons1996–1997 · 2 seasons
Mark ClarkSP1993–1995 · 3 seasons1991–1992 · 2 seasons
Don HoodRP1975–1978 · 4 seasons1980 · 1 season
Ed Crosby—1974–1976 · 3 seasons1970–1972 · 2 seasons
Tom HilgendorfP1972–1974 · 3 seasons1969–1970 · 2 seasons
Bobby TiefenauerP1960–1967 · 2 seasons1952–1961 · 3 seasons
Leon Wagner—1964–1967 · 4 seasons1960 · 1 season
Sam JonesP1951–1952 · 2 seasons1957–1963 · 3 seasons
Duster MailsP1920–1922 · 3 seasons1925–1926 · 2 seasons
Red DonahueP1904–1905 · 2 seasons1895–1897 · 3 seasons
Lane ThomasLF2024–2025 · 2 seasons2019–2020 · 2 seasons
Nick WittgrenRP2019–2021 · 3 seasons2022 · 1 season
Brian TalletRP2002–2005 · 3 seasons2011 · 1 season
Hector Luna1B2006 · 1 season2004–2006 · 3 seasons
Ricardo RinconRP1999–2001 · 3 seasons2006 · 1 season
Ronnie Belliard2B2004–2006 · 3 seasons2006 · 1 season
Jesse OroscoRP1989–1991 · 3 seasons2000 · 1 season
Danny Sheaffer3B1989 · 1 season1995–1997 · 3 seasons
Rick WiseRP1978–1979 · 2 seasons1972–1973 · 2 seasons
Gene Green—1962 · 1 season1957–1959 · 3 seasons
Minnie MinosoDH1949–1959 · 3 seasons1962 · 1 season
Nate AndrewsP1940–1941 · 2 seasons1937–1939 · 2 seasons
Roy WalkerP1912–1915 · 2 seasons1921–1922 · 2 seasons
Dick NiehausP1920 · 1 season1913–1915 · 3 seasons
Bob Bescher—1918 · 1 season1915–1917 · 3 seasons
Herman Bronkie—1910–1912 · 3 seasons1918 · 1 season
Fred BeebeP1916 · 1 season1907–1909 · 3 seasons
Cy YoungP1909–1910 · 2 seasons1899–1900 · 2 seasons
Jake ThielmanP1907–1908 · 2 seasons1905–1906 · 2 seasons
Fritz Buelow—1905–1906 · 2 seasons1899–1900 · 2 seasons
Phil MatonRP2019–2020 · 2 seasons2025 · 1 season
Brandon MossRF2015 · 1 season2015–2016 · 2 seasons
Jess ToddSP2009–2010 · 2 seasons2009 · 1 season
Jose JimenezP2004 · 1 season1998–1999 · 2 seasons
Rich RodriguezRP2001 · 1 season1994–1995 · 2 seasons
Scott RadinskyRP2001 · 1 season1999–2000 · 2 seasons
Tom LampkinC1988 · 1 season1997–1998 · 2 seasons
Rick SutcliffeSP1982–1983 · 2 seasons1994 · 1 season
Dave Von OhlenRP1985 · 1 season1983–1984 · 2 seasons
Lary SorensenRP1982–1983 · 2 seasons1981 · 1 season
Jim BibbyRP1976–1977 · 2 seasons1972 · 1 season
Harry ParkerP1976 · 1 season1970–1971 · 2 seasons
Alan FosterP1971 · 1 season1973–1974 · 2 seasons
Leron Lee—1974 · 1 season1969–1970 · 2 seasons
Alex Johnson—1972 · 1 season1966–1967 · 2 seasons
Dennis HigginsP1970 · 1 season1971–1972 · 2 seasons
Vada Pinson—1970–1971 · 2 seasons1969 · 1 season
Jose Cardenal1B1968–1969 · 2 seasons1970 · 1 season
Roger Maris—1957 · 1 season1967–1968 · 2 seasons
Hal WoodeshickP1958 · 1 season1966–1967 · 2 seasons
Ron TaylorP1962 · 1 season1963–1964 · 2 seasons
Joe Frazier—1947 · 1 season1954–1955 · 2 seasons
Rocky Nelson—1954 · 1 season1949–1950 · 2 seasons
Buster Mills—1942–1946 · 2 seasons1934 · 1 season
Joe Sprinz—1930–1931 · 2 seasons1933 · 1 season
Billy Southworth—1915 · 1 season1927–1929 · 2 seasons
Paddy Livingston—1901–1912 · 2 seasons1917 · 1 season
Grover LowdermilkP1916 · 1 season1909–1911 · 2 seasons
Denney Wilie—1915 · 1 season1911–1912 · 2 seasons
Tom Reilly—1914 · 1 season1908–1909 · 2 seasons
Jap Barbeau—1905–1906 · 2 seasons1910 · 1 season
Josh Clarke—1908–1909 · 2 seasons1905 · 1 season
Danny Shay—1901 · 1 season1904–1905 · 2 seasons
Bill HartP1901 · 1 season1896–1897 · 2 seasons
Richie Palacios2B2022 · 1 season2023 · 1 season
Matt BelisleRP2018 · 1 season2015 · 1 season
Preston GuilmetRP2013 · 1 season2018 · 1 season
Mark Reynolds1B2013 · 1 season2015 · 1 season
George KottarasC2014 · 1 season2014 · 1 season
John AxfordRP2014 · 1 season2013 · 1 season
Arthur RhodesRP2005 · 1 season2011 · 1 season
Mark Grudzielanek2B2010 · 1 season2005 · 1 season
Mark DeRosa2B2009 · 1 season2009 · 1 season
Josh Phelps1B2004 · 1 season2008 · 1 season
Ron VilloneRP1998 · 1 season2008 · 1 season
Mark LittleOF2004 · 1 season1998 · 1 season
Rich DeLuciaRP1999 · 1 season1995 · 1 season
Ted PowerP1992 · 1 season1989 · 1 season
Rafael SantanaSS1990 · 1 season1983 · 1 season
Mark SalasC1989 · 1 season1984 · 1 season
Neil AllenRP1989 · 1 season1984 · 1 season
Bennie AyalaDH1985 · 1 season1977 · 1 season
Bobby BondsCF1979 · 1 season1980 · 1 season
Doug Howard—1976 · 1 season1975 · 1 season
Joe Morgan—1961 · 1 season1964 · 1 season
Al CicotteP1959 · 1 season1961 · 1 season
Al GettelP1947 · 1 season1955 · 1 season
Tim MurchisonP1920 · 1 season1917 · 1 season
Hi JasperP1919 · 1 season1916 · 1 season
Ken Nash—1912 · 1 season1914 · 1 season
Hugh Hill—1903 · 1 season1904 · 1 season
Alex PearsonP1903 · 1 season1902 · 1 season
Russ Hall—1901 · 1 season1898 · 1 season

Regular season, under every name each club has played as. A season split by a trade counts for both clubs where the game logs reach it (NBA from 1993-94, NFL 1994, NHL 1996, MLB 2001). Longest stay with the two first.

Cleveland Guardians vs St. Louis Cardinals: head-to-head record →