Ed Reulbach vs Eddie Cicotte

Ed Reulbach Eddie Cicotte

Ed Reulbach and Eddie Cicotte compared on their MLB careers: Ed Reulbach played 13 seasons, 1905 to 1917, Eddie Cicotte 14 seasons, 1905 to 1920. Ed Reulbach has 182 wins to Eddie Cicotte's 208. Ed Reulbach won 2 titles, Eddie Cicotte won 2 titles.

Who has the better career numbers?

Ed Reulbach and Eddie Cicotte career totals

399	GP	502
182	W	208
106	L	149
2.3	ERA	2.4
2632.1	IP	3223.1
1,138	K	1,374
892	BB	827
1.1	WHIP	1.2
13	SV	25

How do they compare in the postseason?

Ed Reulbach and Eddie Cicotte postseason

7	GP	6
0	R	0
24	H	42

Where each stands all time

Ed Reulbach and Eddie Cicotte all-time places

159th (182)	Wins (pitching)	100th (208)
—	Strikeouts (pitching)	292nd (1,374)

Among the MLB players with a career line on file, regular season, counting stats only — the same lists the records pages run on.

Titles and awards

Ed Reulbach: 2 championships; none on file
Eddie Cicotte: 2 championships; none on file

Awards come from the league’s published winner lists; a championship counts a season played for the club that won it.

Season by season

Lined up by career year, not by calendar: each row is the players’ nth season.

Ed Reulbach and Eddie Cicotte season by season

1st	1905	18	14	1.42	1905	1	1	3.50
2nd	1906	19	4	1.65	1908	11	12	2.43
3rd	1907	17	4	1.69	1909	13	5	1.97
4th	1908	24	7	2.03	1910	15	11	2.74
5th	1909	19	10	1.78	1911	11	15	2.82
6th	1910	12	8	3.12	1912	10	10	3.50
7th	1911	16	9	2.96	1913	18	12	1.58
8th	1912	10	6	3.78	1914	11	16	2.04
9th	1913	8	9	2.66	1915	13	12	3.02
10th	1914	11	18	2.64	1916	15	7	1.78
11th	1915	21	10	2.23	1917	28	12	1.53
12th	1916	7	6	2.47	1918	12	19	2.77
13th	1917	0	1	2.82	1919	29	7	1.82
14th	—	—	—	—	1920	21	10	3.26

What the columns mean: W · L · ERA