Allie Reynolds vs Hal Newhouser

Allie Reynolds Hal Newhouser

Allie Reynolds and Hal Newhouser compared on their MLB careers: Allie Reynolds played 13 seasons, 1942 to 1954, Hal Newhouser 17 seasons, 1939 to 1955. Allie Reynolds has 182 wins to Hal Newhouser's 207. Allie Reynolds won 6 titles, Hal Newhouser won 1 title.

Who has the better career numbers?

Allie Reynolds and Hal Newhouser career totals

434	GP	488
182	W	207
107	L	150
3.3	ERA	3.1
2492.1	IP	2,993
1,423	K	1,796
1,261	BB	1,249
1.4	WHIP	1.3
49	SV	26

How do they compare in the postseason?

Allie Reynolds and Hal Newhouser postseason

15	GP	4
0	R	0
61	H	26

Where each stands all time

Allie Reynolds and Hal Newhouser all-time places

267th (1,423)	Strikeouts (pitching)	131st (1,796)
159th (182)	Wins (pitching)	101st (207)

Among the MLB players with a career line on file, regular season, counting stats only — the same lists the records pages run on.

Titles and awards

Allie Reynolds: 6 championships; none on file
Hal Newhouser: 1 championship; AL MVP ×2

Awards come from the league’s published winner lists; a championship counts a season played for the club that won it.

Season by season

Lined up by career year, not by calendar: each row is the players’ nth season.

Allie Reynolds and Hal Newhouser season by season

1st	1942	0	0	0.00	1939	0	1	5.40
2nd	1943	11	12	2.99	1940	9	9	4.86
3rd	1944	11	8	3.30	1941	9	11	4.79
4th	1945	18	12	3.20	1942	8	14	2.45
5th	1946	11	15	3.88	1943	8	17	3.04
6th	1947	19	8	3.20	1944	29	9	2.22
7th	1948	16	7	3.77	1945	25	9	1.81
8th	1949	17	6	4.00	1946	26	9	1.94
9th	1950	16	12	3.74	1947	17	17	2.87
10th	1951	17	8	3.05	1948	21	12	3.01
11th	1952	20	8	2.06	1949	18	11	3.36
12th	1953	13	7	3.41	1950	15	13	4.34
13th	1954	13	4	3.32	1951	6	6	3.92
14th	—	—	—	—	1952	9	9	3.74
15th	—	—	—	—	1953	0	1	7.06
16th	—	—	—	—	1954	7	2	2.51
17th	—	—	—	—	1955	0	0	0.00

What the columns mean: W · L · ERA