Carlos Ivan Beltran | OF | 1998–2017 | 20 | 2,725 H · 435 HR · 66.8 WAR | Manati, Puerto Rico |
| Roberto Alomar | 2B | 1988–2004 | 17 | 2,724 H · 210 HR · 62.9 WAR | Ponce, Puerto Rico |
| Jose Cruz | RF | 1970–1988 | 19 | 2,251 H · 165 HR · 51.0 WAR | Arroyo, Puerto Rico |
| Bernie Williams | RF | 1991–2006 | 16 | 2,336 H · 287 HR · 45.9 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Carlos Delgado | 1B | 1993–2009 | 17 | 2,038 H · 473 HR · 40.4 WAR | Aguadilla, Puerto Rico |
Javier Vazquez | SP | 1998–2011 | 14 | 165 W · 2,536 SO · 40.2 WAR | Ponce, Puerto Rico |
Yadier Molina | C | 2004–2022 | 19 | 2,168 H · 176 HR · 39.2 WAR | Bayamon, Puerto Rico |
Jorge Posada | DH | 1996–2011 | 16 | 1,664 H · 275 HR · 39.0 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
| Juan Alberto Gonzalez | — | 1989–2005 | 17 | 1,936 H · 434 HR · 35.1 WAR | Vega Baja, Puerto Rico |
| Jose Valentin | 2B | 1992–2007 | 16 | 1,348 H · 249 HR · 28.8 WAR | Manati, Puerto Rico |
| Javy Lopez | C | 1992–2006 | 15 | 1,527 H · 260 HR · 27.2 WAR | Ponce, Puerto Rico |
| Sixto Lezcano | CF | 1974–1985 | 12 | 1,122 H · 148 HR · 25.8 WAR | Arecibo, Puerto Rico |
| Benito Santiago | C | 1986–2005 | 20 | 1,830 H · 217 HR · 24.5 WAR | Ponce, Puerto Rico |
| Mike Lowell | 1B | 1998–2010 | 13 | 1,619 H · 223 HR · 21.9 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Danny Tartabull | RF | 1984–1997 | 14 | 1,366 H · 262 HR · 20.8 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Rey Sanchez | 2B | 1991–2005 | 15 | 1,317 H · 15 HR · 18.3 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
| Carlos Baerga | 3B | 1990–2005 | 14 | 1,583 H · 134 HR · 17.2 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Jose L Cruz Jr. | OF | 1997–2008 | 12 | 1,167 H · 204 HR · 17.1 WAR | Arroyo, Puerto Rico |
Angel Pagan | LF | 2006–2016 | 11 | 1,143 H · 64 HR · 16.5 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
| Roberto Hernandez | RP | 1991–2007 | 17 | 67 W · 945 SO · 16.0 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
| Ed Figueroa | SP | 1974–1981 | 8 | 80 W · 571 SO · 15.6 WAR | Ciales, Puerto Rico |
| Willie Hernandez | RP | 1977–1989 | 13 | 70 W · 788 SO · 15.2 WAR | Aguada, Puerto Rico |
| Jose Vidro | DH | 1997–2008 | 12 | 1,524 H · 128 HR · 14.9 WAR | Mayaguez, Puerto Rico |
| Orlando Merced | RF | 1990–2003 | 13 | 1,108 H · 103 HR · 14.5 WAR | Hato Rey, Puerto Rico |
| Ruben Sierra | DH | 1986–2006 | 20 | 2,152 H · 306 HR · 13.0 WAR | Rio Pedras, Puerto Rico |
Jose Oquendo | 2B | 1983–1995 | 12 | 821 H · 14 HR · 12.4 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
| Jose Guzman | P | 1985–1994 | 8 | 80 W · 889 SO · 12.2 WAR | Santa Isabel, Puerto Rico |
| Tony Bernazard | 2B | 1979–1991 | 10 | 970 H · 75 HR · 11.6 WAR | Caguas, Puerto Rico |
| Jose Hernandez | 1B | 1991–2006 | 15 | 1,166 H · 168 HR · 11.5 WAR | Vega Alta, Puerto Rico |
Joel Pineiro | SP | 2000–2011 | 12 | 104 W · 1,058 SO · 11.2 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
Geovany Soto | C | 2005–2017 | 13 | 619 H · 108 HR · 11.1 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Ivan Calderon | — | 1984–1993 | 10 | 901 H · 104 HR · 10.2 WAR | Fajardo, Puerto Rico |
Eddie Rosario | OF | 2015–2025 | 11 | 1,064 H · 169 HR · 10.1 WAR | Guayama, Puerto Rico |
| Luis Alicea | 2B | 1988–2002 | 13 | 1,031 H · 47 HR · 9.8 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
| Carmelo Martinez | 1B | 1983–1991 | 9 | 713 H · 108 HR · 9.8 WAR | Dorado, Puerto Rico |
| Luis Aquino | RP | 1986–1995 | 9 | 31 W · 318 SO · 9.7 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
| Ivan DeJesus | SS | 1974–1988 | 15 | 1,167 H · 21 HR · 9.5 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
| Otto Velez | DH | 1973–1983 | 11 | 452 H · 78 HR · 9.0 WAR | Ponce, Puerto Rico |
| Leo Gomez | 3B | 1990–1996 | 7 | 466 H · 79 HR · 9.0 WAR | Carnovanas, Puerto Rico |
| Bengie Molina | C | 1998–2010 | 13 | 1,317 H · 144 HR · 8.3 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
| Candy Maldonado | LF | 1981–1995 | 15 | 1,042 H · 146 HR · 8.1 WAR | Humacao, Puerto Rico |
Javier Lopez | RP | 2003–2016 | 14 | 30 W · 358 SO · 7.8 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Jaime Navarro | RP | 1989–2000 | 12 | 116 W · 1,113 SO · 7.8 WAR | Bayamon, Puerto Rico |
| Ozzie Virgil | C | 1980–1990 | 11 | 549 H · 98 HR · 7.8 WAR | Mayaguez, Puerto Rico |
| Omar Olivares | RP | 1990–2001 | 12 | 77 W · 853 SO · 7.7 WAR | Mayaguez, Puerto Rico |
| Juan Beniquez | LF | 1971–1988 | 17 | 1,274 H · 79 HR · 7.5 WAR | San Sebastian, Puerto Rico |
J.C. Romero | RP | 1999–2012 | 14 | 34 W · 526 SO · 6.7 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
Martin Maldonado | C | 2011–2025 | 15 | 731 H · 119 HR · 6.3 WAR | Naguabo, Puerto Rico |
Joey Cora | 2B | 1987–1998 | 11 | 1,035 H · 30 HR · 6.2 WAR | Caguas, Puerto Rico |
Ricky Bones | RP | 1991–2001 | 11 | 63 W · 564 SO · 6.0 WAR | Salinas, Puerto Rico |
Alex Claudio | RP | 2014–2023 | 10 | 16 W · 249 SO · 6.0 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
Felipe Lopez | 2B | 2001–2011 | 11 | 1,145 H · 90 HR · 5.9 WAR | Bayamon, Puerto Rico |
| Kiko Calero | RP | 2003–2009 | 7 | 14 W · 324 SO · 5.9 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
Alex Cora | SS | 1998–2011 | 14 | 828 H · 35 HR · 5.4 WAR | Caguas, Puerto Rico |
Pedro Feliciano | RP | 2002–2013 | 9 | 22 W · 350 SO · 5.3 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
Alexis Diaz | RP | 2022–2025 | 4 | 19 W · 241 SO · 4.7 WAR | Humacao, Puerto Rico |
| Wil Cordero | 1B | 1992–2005 | 14 | 1,178 H · 122 HR · 4.0 WAR | Mayaguez, Puerto Rico |
| Luis Matos | LF | 2000–2006 | 7 | 410 H · 30 HR · 3.8 WAR | Bayamon, Puerto Rico |
| Angel Miranda | RP | 1993–1997 | 5 | 17 W · 243 SO · 3.8 WAR | Arecibo, Puerto Rico |
| Edwin Nunez | RP | 1982–1994 | 13 | 28 W · 508 SO · 3.3 WAR | Humacao, Puerto Rico |
| Juan Nieves | SP | 1986–1988 | 3 | 32 W · 352 SO · 2.9 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
| Luis DeLeon | SP | 1981–1989 | 7 | 17 W · 248 SO · 2.8 WAR | Ponce, Puerto Rico |
| Luis Aguayo | 3B | 1980–1989 | 10 | 260 H · 37 HR · 2.3 WAR | Vega Baja, Puerto Rico |
| Armando Rios | OF | 1998–2003 | 6 | 275 H · 36 HR · 2.3 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
| Jose Melendez | RP | 1990–1994 | 5 | 16 W · 172 SO · 2.2 WAR | Naguabo, Puerto Rico |
Rene Rivera | C | 2004–2021 | 13 | 330 H · 43 HR · 2.1 WAR | Bayamon, Puerto Rico |
| Jose Lind | 2B | 1987–1995 | 9 | 935 H · 9 HR · 2.1 WAR | Toabaja, Puerto Rico |
| Bombo Rivera | CF | 1975–1982 | 6 | 220 H · 10 HR · 2.1 WAR | Ponce, Puerto Rico |
| Ricky Ledee | LF | 1998–2007 | 10 | 494 H · 63 HR · 1.9 WAR | Ponce, Puerto Rico |
Emmanuel Rivera | 3B | 2021–2025 | 5 | 260 H · 22 HR · 1.9 WAR | Mayagüez, Puerto Rico |
Jonathan Sanchez | SP | 2006–2013 | 8 | 39 W · 796 SO · 1.8 WAR | Mayaguez, Puerto Rico |
| Saul Rivera | RP | 2006–2010 | 5 | 13 W · 192 SO · 1.7 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Jamie Cocanower | RP | 1983–1986 | 4 | 16 W · 139 SO · 1.7 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Mike Perez | RP | 1990–1997 | 8 | 24 W · 224 SO · 1.6 WAR | Yauco, Puerto Rico |
Christian Colon | 2B | 2014–2020 | 6 | 94 H · 1 HR · 1.6 WAR | Cayey, Puerto Rico |
| Juan Bonilla | 2B | 1981–1987 | 6 | 375 H · 7 HR · 1.6 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
Joe Jimenez | RP | 2017–2024 | 8 | 20 W · 488 SO · 1.5 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Juan Padilla | RP | 2004–2005 | 2 | 4 W · 34 SO · 1.5 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
| Hector Villanueva | C | 1990–1993 | 4 | 109 H · 25 HR · 1.4 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
| Rico Rossy | 3B | 1991–1998 | 4 | 67 H · 4 HR · 1.4 WAR | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Jose Santiago | RP | 1997–2005 | 8 | 17 W · 153 SO · 1.3 WAR | Fajardo, Puerto Rico |
| Julio Valera | RP | 1990–1996 | 5 | 15 W · 179 SO · 1.3 WAR | Aguadilla, Puerto Rico |
| Francisco Oliveras | RP | 1989–1992 | 4 | 11 W · 130 SO · 1.3 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
| Juan Agosto | RP | 1981–1993 | 13 | 40 W · 307 SO · 1.2 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
| Edwin Correa | SP | 1985–1987 | 3 | 16 W · 260 SO · 1.0 WAR | Hato Rey, Puerto Rico |
| Bennie Ayala | DH | 1974–1985 | 10 | 217 H · 38 HR · 0.7 WAR | Yauco, Puerto Rico |
Hector Ortiz | C | 1998–2002 | 4 | 75 H · 1 HR · 0.7 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
| German Rivera | 3B | 1983–1985 | 3 | 72 H · 2 HR · 0.7 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
Ramon Vazquez | SS | 2001–2009 | 9 | 496 H · 22 HR · 0.6 WAR | Cayey, Puerto Rico |
Jose Morales | C | 2007–2011 | 4 | 63 H · 0 HR · 0.6 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
Carlos Corporan | C | 2009–2015 | 6 | 153 H · 20 HR · 0.4 WAR | Hato Rey, Puerto Rico |
| Felipe Crespo | LF | 1996–2001 | 5 | 109 H · 10 HR · 0.4 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
| Javier Valentin | C | 1997–2008 | 10 | 379 H · 45 HR · 0.3 WAR | Manati, Puerto Rico |
| Hector Mercado | RP | 2000–2003 | 4 | 5 W · 127 SO · 0.3 WAR | Catano, Puerto Rico |
Irving Falu | 2B | 2012–2014 | 3 | 33 H · 0 HR · 0.3 WAR | Hato Rey, Puerto Rico |
| Tony Rodriguez | SS | 1996 | 1 | 16 H · 1 HR · 0.3 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |
| Damon Mashore | RF | 1996–1998 | 3 | 120 H · 8 HR · 0.2 WAR | Ponce, Puerto Rico |
Edwin Maysonet | 2B | 2008–2012 | 3 | 36 H · 2 HR · 0.2 WAR | Arecibo, Puerto Rico |
| Chico Ruiz | 3B | 1978–1980 | 2 | 21 H · 0 HR · 0.2 WAR | Santurce, Puerto Rico |
Mike Rivera | C | 2001–2011 | 9 | 131 H · 13 HR · 0.1 WAR | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico |