Players who played for the New York Islanders and Toronto Maple Leafs

New York Islanders
Toronto Maple Leafs

52 players

52 players have played for both the New York Islanders and the Toronto Maple Leafs. John Tavares spent the most seasons with the two: 9 with the New York Islanders and 8 with the Toronto Maple Leafs. On a roster now: John Tavares, Pierre Engvall, and David Rittich. Rosters are on file in full from 1993-94; before that only some of the stars are.

Players who played for the New York Islanders and the Toronto Maple Leafs, with their years at each
PlayerPosNYITOR
John TavaresC2009–2018 · 9 seasons2018–2026 · 8 seasons
Matt MartinLW2009–2025 · 14 seasons2016–2018 · 2 seasons
Derek KingLW1986–1997 · 11 seasons1997–2000 · 3 seasons
Wendel ClarkLW1995–1996 · 1 season1985–2000 · 13 seasons
Kenny JonssonD1995–2004 · 9 seasons1994–1996 · 2 seasons
Nikolay KuleminLW2014–2018 · 4 seasons2008–2014 · 6 seasons
Bryan McCabeD1995–1998 · 3 seasons2000–2008 · 7 seasons
Felix PotvinG1998–2000 · 2 seasons1991–1999 · 8 seasons
Jason BlakeLW2000–2007 · 6 seasons2007–2010 · 3 seasons
Travis GreenC1992–1998 · 6 seasons2001–2007 · 3 seasons
Steve ThomasRW1992–1995 · 3 seasons1984–2001 · 6 seasons
Glenn HealyG1989–1993 · 4 seasons1997–2001 · 4 seasons
Randy WoodRW1986–1997 · 6 seasons1994–1996 · 2 seasons
Pierre EngvallLW2022–2025 · 3 seasons2019–2023 · 4 seasons
Mikhail GrabovskiC2014–2016 · 2 seasons2008–2013 · 5 seasons
Mariusz CzerkawskiRW1997–2004 · 6 seasons2005–2006 · 1 season
Tom FitzgeraldRW1988–1993 · 5 seasons2002–2004 · 2 seasons
Gerald DiduckD1984–1990 · 6 seasons1999–2000 · 1 season
Michael GrabnerRW2010–2015 · 5 seasons2015–2016 · 1 season
Bryan BerardD1996–2008 · 4 seasons1998–2000 · 2 seasons
Robert ReichelC1996–1999 · 3 seasons2001–2004 · 3 seasons
Darby HendricksonC1995–1996 · 1 season1994–1999 · 5 seasons
Bill BergLW1988–1992 · 3 seasons1993–1996 · 3 seasons
Joe SaccoLW1997–1999 · 2 seasons1990–1993 · 3 seasons
Ken BelangerLW1995–1999 · 4 seasons1994–1995 · 1 season
Ken BaumgartnerLW1990–1991 · 1 season1992–1996 · 4 seasons
Michael PecaC2001–2004 · 3 seasons2006–2007 · 1 season
Scott PearsonLW1999–2000 · 1 season1988–1997 · 3 seasons
David HarlockD1998–1999 · 1 season1993–1996 · 3 seasons
Mathieu SchneiderD1995–1996 · 1 season1995–1998 · 3 seasons
Daniel MaroisRW1992–1993 · 1 season1988–1991 · 3 seasons
P.A. ParenteauRW2010–2012 · 2 seasons2015–2016 · 1 season
Eric BrewerD1998–2000 · 2 seasons2014–2015 · 1 season
Tim ConnollyC1999–2001 · 2 seasons2011–2012 · 1 season
Joey MacDonaldG2007–2009 · 2 seasons2009–2010 · 1 season
Jeff HamiltonC2003–2006 · 2 seasons2008–2009 · 1 season
Alexander KarpovtsevD2003–2004 · 1 season1998–2000 · 2 seasons
Jason PodollanRW2001–2002 · 1 season1996–1999 · 2 seasons
Jamie HewardD1999–2000 · 1 season1995–1997 · 2 seasons
Sean HaggertyLW1997–2000 · 2 seasons1995–1996 · 1 season
Marco CousineauG1998–1999 · 1 season1996–1998 · 2 seasons
Kirk MullerLW1995–1996 · 1 season1995–1997 · 2 seasons
Benoit HogueLW1992–1994 · 2 seasons1995–1996 · 1 season
Brian CurranD1986–1987 · 1 season1988–1990 · 2 seasons
David RittichG2025–2026 · 1 season2020–2021 · 1 season
Richard PanikRW2021–2022 · 1 season2014–2015 · 1 season
Brad BoyesRW2012–2013 · 1 season2015–2016 · 1 season
Olli JokinenC1999–2000 · 1 season2014–2015 · 1 season
Dallas EakinsD1999–2000 · 1 season1998–1999 · 1 season
Mike KennedyC1998–1999 · 1 season1997–1998 · 1 season
Dave McLlwainLW1996–1997 · 1 season1992–1993 · 1 season
Bob HalkidisD1995–1996 · 1 season1991–1992 · 1 season

Regular season, under every name each club has played as. A season split by a trade counts for both clubs where the game logs reach it (NBA from 1993-94, NFL 1994, NHL 1996, MLB 2001). Longest stay with the two first.

New York Islanders vs Toronto Maple Leafs: head-to-head record →