Players who played for the Pittsburgh Pirates and Toronto Blue Jays
80 players
80 players have played for both the Pittsburgh Pirates and the Toronto Blue Jays. Jose Bautista spent the most seasons with the two: 5 with the Pittsburgh Pirates and 10 with the Toronto Blue Jays. On a roster now: Tim Mayza, Tyler Heineman, Spencer Horwitz, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, and Brandon Eisert. Every season since 1876 is on file.
| Player | Pos | PIT | TOR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jose Bautista | RF | 2004–2008 · 5 seasons | 2008–2017 · 10 seasons |
| Bob Robertson | — | 1967–1976 · 9 seasons | 1979 · 1 season |
| Ryan Borucki | RP | 2023–2025 · 3 seasons | 2018–2025 · 6 seasons |
| Travis Snider | RF | 2012–2015 · 4 seasons | 2008–2012 · 5 seasons |
| Tim Mayza | RP | 2025 · 1 season | 2017–2024 · 7 seasons |
| John McDonald | 3B | 2013 · 1 season | 2005–2011 · 7 seasons |
| Ed Sprague Jr. | 1B | 1999 · 1 season | 1991–1997 · 7 seasons |
| Carlos Garcia | 3B | 1990–1996 · 7 seasons | 1997 · 1 season |
| Orlando Merced | RF | 1990–1996 · 7 seasons | 1997 · 1 season |
| Tyler Heineman | C | 2022–2023 · 2 seasons | 2022–2026 · 5 seasons |
| Francisco Liriano | RP | 2013–2019 · 5 seasons | 2016–2017 · 2 seasons |
| J.A. Happ | SP | 2015 · 1 season | 2012–2018 · 6 seasons |
| Steve Pearce | 1B | 2007–2011 · 5 seasons | 2017–2018 · 2 seasons |
| Russell Martin | C | 2013–2014 · 2 seasons | 2015–2018 · 4 seasons |
| Jason Grilli | RP | 2011–2014 · 4 seasons | 2016–2017 · 2 seasons |
| A.J. Burnett | SP | 2012–2015 · 3 seasons | 2006–2008 · 3 seasons |
| Lyle Overbay | 1B | 2011 · 1 season | 2006–2010 · 5 seasons |
| Eric Hinske | OF | 2009 · 1 season | 2002–2006 · 5 seasons |
| Josh Phelps | 1B | 2007 · 1 season | 2000–2004 · 5 seasons |
| Jose Silva | RP | 1997–2001 · 5 seasons | 1996 · 1 season |
| Jim Gott | RP | 1988–1995 · 3 seasons | 1982–1984 · 3 seasons |
| Jameson Taillon | SP | 2016–2019 · 4 seasons | 2026 · 1 season |
| Drew Hutchison | SP | 2016 · 1 season | 2012–2016 · 4 seasons |
| Brad Lincoln | RP | 2010–2012 · 3 seasons | 2012–2013 · 2 seasons |
| Rajai Davis | CF | 2006–2007 · 2 seasons | 2011–2013 · 3 seasons |
| Esteban Loaiza | RP | 1995–1997 · 3 seasons | 2001–2002 · 2 seasons |
| Dan Plesac | RP | 1995–1996 · 2 seasons | 1997–2001 · 3 seasons |
| Nelson Liriano | 2B | 1995–1996 · 2 seasons | 1987–1989 · 3 seasons |
| Spencer Horwitz | 1B | 2025–2026 · 2 seasons | 2023–2024 · 2 seasons |
| Isiah Kiner-Falefa | 2B | 2024–2025 · 2 seasons | 2024–2025 · 2 seasons |
| Rowdy Tellez | 1B | 2024 · 1 season | 2018–2020 · 3 seasons |
| Jesse Chavez | RP | 2008–2009 · 2 seasons | 2012–2016 · 2 seasons |
| Andy LaRoche | 3B | 2008–2010 · 3 seasons | 2013 · 1 season |
| Chad Hermansen | OF | 1999–2001 · 3 seasons | 2004 · 1 season |
| Steve Parris | SP | 1995–1996 · 2 seasons | 2001–2002 · 2 seasons |
| Turner Ward | RF | 1997–1998 · 2 seasons | 1992–1993 · 2 seasons |
| Dennis Lamp | RP | 1992 · 1 season | 1984–1986 · 3 seasons |
| Doug Bair | RP | 1976–1990 · 3 seasons | 1988 · 1 season |
| Ken Macha | 3B | 1974–1978 · 3 seasons | 1981 · 1 season |
| Cody Ponce | SP | 2020–2021 · 2 seasons | 2026 · 1 season |
| Genesis Cabrera | RP | 2025 · 1 season | 2023–2024 · 2 seasons |
| Melky Cabrera | RF | 2019 · 1 season | 2013–2014 · 2 seasons |
| Nick Kingham | RP | 2018–2019 · 2 seasons | 2019 · 1 season |
| Erik Kratz | C | 2010–2016 · 2 seasons | 2014 · 1 season |
| Matt Donald Hague | 1B | 2012–2014 · 2 seasons | 2015 · 1 season |
| Juan Perez | RP | 2006–2007 · 2 seasons | 2013 · 1 season |
| Rod Barajas | C | 2012 · 1 season | 2008–2009 · 2 seasons |
| Brian Burres | SP | 2010–2011 · 2 seasons | 2009 · 1 season |
| Bryan Bullington | RP | 2005–2007 · 2 seasons | 2009 · 1 season |
| Robinzon Diaz | C | 2008–2009 · 2 seasons | 2008 · 1 season |
| Matt Stairs | 1B | 2003 · 1 season | 2007–2008 · 2 seasons |
| Ty Taubenheim | RP | 2008 · 1 season | 2006–2007 · 2 seasons |
| Benito Santiago | C | 2005 · 1 season | 1997–1998 · 2 seasons |
| Miguel Batista | SP | 1992 · 1 season | 2004–2005 · 2 seasons |
| Raul Mondesi | RF | 2004 · 1 season | 2000–2001 · 2 seasons |
| Derek Bell | RF | 2001 · 1 season | 1991–1992 · 2 seasons |
| Mark Ross | RP | 1987–1990 · 2 seasons | 1988 · 1 season |
| Brandon Eisert | RP | 2026 · 1 season | 2024 · 1 season |
| Justin Bruihl | RP | 2024 · 1 season | 2025 · 1 season |
| Anthony Banda | RP | 2022 · 1 season | 2022 · 1 season |
| Daniel Hudson | RP | 2017 · 1 season | 2019 · 1 season |
| Adeiny Hechavarria | 2B | 2018 · 1 season | 2012 · 1 season |
| Gift Ngoepe | 3B | 2017 · 1 season | 2018 · 1 season |
| John Axford | RP | 2014 · 1 season | 2018 · 1 season |
| Joaquin Benoit | RP | 2017 · 1 season | 2016 · 1 season |
| Phil Coke | RP | 2016 · 1 season | 2015 · 1 season |
| Jayson Nix | SS | 2014 · 1 season | 2011 · 1 season |
| John Buck | C | 2013 · 1 season | 2010 · 1 season |
| Octavio Dotel | RP | 2010 · 1 season | 2011 · 1 season |
| Wil J Ledezma | RP | 2010 · 1 season | 2011 · 1 season |
| Dana Eveland | RP | 2010 · 1 season | 2010 · 1 season |
| Raul Chavez | C | 2008 · 1 season | 2009 · 1 season |
| Chris Gomez | 3B | 2008 · 1 season | 2004 · 1 season |
| Cesar Izturis | SS | 2007 · 1 season | 2001 · 1 season |
| John Wasdin | RP | 2007 · 1 season | 2003 · 1 season |
| Luis Figueroa | SS | 2001 · 1 season | 2006 · 1 season |
| Jacob Brumfield | CF | 1995 · 1 season | 1997 · 1 season |
| Lance Parrish | C | 1994 · 1 season | 1995 · 1 season |
| Victor Cruz | RP | 1981 · 1 season | 1978 · 1 season |
| Chuck Hartenstein | P | 1969 · 1 season | 1977 · 1 season |
Regular season, under every name each club has played as. A season split by a trade counts for both clubs where the game logs reach it (NBA from 1993-94, NFL 1994, NHL 1996, MLB 2001). Longest stay with the two first.
Pittsburgh Pirates vs Toronto Blue Jays: head-to-head record →