Players who played for the New York Yankees and Toronto Blue Jays

New York Yankees
Toronto Blue Jays

105 players

105 players have played for both the New York Yankees and the Toronto Blue Jays. Vernon Wells spent the most seasons with the two: 1 with the New York Yankees and 12 with the Toronto Blue Jays. On a roster now: Tim Mayza, Randal Grichuk, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Ryan Yarbrough, and Ali Sanchez. Every season since 1876 is on file.

Players who played for the New York Yankees and the Toronto Blue Jays, with their years at each
PlayerPosNYYTOR
Vernon WellsLF2013 · 1 season1999–2010 · 12 seasons
Jimmy KeyRP1993–1996 · 4 seasons1984–1992 · 9 seasons
David WellsSP1997–2003 · 4 seasons1987–2000 · 8 seasons
Tony FernandezDH1995 · 1 season1983–1999 · 10 seasons
Jesse BarfieldRF1990–1992 · 3 seasons1981–1988 · 8 seasons
Rick CeroneC1980–1990 · 7 seasons1977–1979 · 3 seasons
Otto VelezDH1973–1976 · 4 seasons1977–1982 · 6 seasons
J.A. HappSP2018–2020 · 3 seasons2012–2018 · 6 seasons
Edwin EncarnacionDH2019 · 1 season2009–2016 · 8 seasons
Al LeiterSP1987–2005 · 3 seasons1990–1995 · 6 seasons
John Olerud1B2004 · 1 season1989–1996 · 8 seasons
Dave WinfieldDH1981–1988 · 8 seasons1992 · 1 season
Damaso Garcia2B1978–1979 · 2 seasons1980–1986 · 7 seasons
Marcus StromanSP2024–2025 · 2 seasons2014–2019 · 6 seasons
Tim MayzaRP2024 · 1 season2017–2024 · 7 seasons
Roger ClemensSP1999–2007 · 6 seasons1997–1998 · 2 seasons
Paul QuantrillRP2004–2005 · 2 seasons1996–2001 · 6 seasons
Pat Kelly2B1991–1997 · 7 seasons1999 · 1 season
Melky CabreraRF2005–2009 · 5 seasons2013–2014 · 2 seasons
Luis Sojo1B1997–2003 · 5 seasons1990–1993 · 2 seasons
Josh Donaldson3B2022–2023 · 2 seasons2015–2018 · 4 seasons
David PhelpsRP2012–2014 · 3 seasons2019–2022 · 3 seasons
Russell MartinC2011–2012 · 2 seasons2015–2018 · 4 seasons
Chien-Ming WangRP2005–2009 · 5 seasons2013 · 1 season
Lyle Overbay1B2013 · 1 season2006–2010 · 5 seasons
A.J. BurnettSP2009–2011 · 3 seasons2006–2008 · 3 seasons
Eric HinskeOF2009 · 1 season2002–2006 · 5 seasons
Josh TowersRP2009 · 1 season2003–2007 · 5 seasons
Josh Phelps1B2007 · 1 season2000–2004 · 5 seasons
Homer Bush2B1997–2004 · 3 seasons1999–2001 · 3 seasons
Randal GrichukDH2026 · 1 season2018–2021 · 4 seasons
Curtis GrandersonLF2010–2013 · 4 seasons2018 · 1 season
Dewayne WiseCF2012 · 1 season2000–2011 · 4 seasons
Ted LillySP2000–2001 · 2 seasons2004–2006 · 3 seasons
Cecil FielderDH1997 · 1 season1985–1988 · 4 seasons
Isiah Kiner-Falefa2B2022–2023 · 2 seasons2024–2025 · 2 seasons
Gio Urshela3B2019–2021 · 3 seasons2018 · 1 season
Brandon Drury2B2018 · 1 season2018–2020 · 3 seasons
Troy TulowitzkiSS2019 · 1 season2015–2017 · 3 seasons
Tyler ClippardRP2007–2017 · 3 seasons2018 · 1 season
Rob RefsnyderDH2015–2017 · 3 seasons2017 · 1 season
Dioner NavarroC2004 · 1 season2014–2016 · 3 seasons
Phil CokeRP2008–2016 · 3 seasons2015 · 1 season
Esmil RogersRP2014–2015 · 2 seasons2013–2014 · 2 seasons
Sergio SantosRP2015 · 1 season2012–2014 · 3 seasons
Juan RiveraLF2001–2003 · 3 seasons2011 · 1 season
Kevin CashC2009 · 1 season2002–2004 · 3 seasons
Miguel Cairo1B2004–2007 · 3 seasons1996 · 1 season
Tanyon SturtzeRP2004–2006 · 3 seasons2003 · 1 season
Bob MacDonaldRP1995 · 1 season1990–1992 · 3 seasons
Cliff JohnsonDH1978 · 1 season1983–1986 · 3 seasons
Dale MurrayRP1983–1984 · 2 seasons1981–1982 · 2 seasons
Mickey Klutts3B1976–1978 · 3 seasons1983 · 1 season
Tom BuskeyRP1973 · 1 season1978–1980 · 3 seasons
Jameson TaillonSP2021–2022 · 2 seasons2026 · 1 season
Ryan YarbroughRP2025–2026 · 2 seasons2024 · 1 season
Mark Leiter Jr.RP2024–2025 · 2 seasons2018 · 1 season
A.J. ColeRP2018 · 1 season2020–2021 · 2 seasons
Erik KratzC2017–2020 · 2 seasons2014 · 1 season
Kendrys MoralesDH2019 · 1 season2017–2018 · 2 seasons
Steve Pearce1B2012 · 1 season2017–2018 · 2 seasons
Kelly Johnson2B2014 · 1 season2011–2012 · 2 seasons
Aaron LaffeySP2011 · 1 season2012–2013 · 2 seasons
Jayson NixSS2012–2013 · 2 seasons2011 · 1 season
Chad GaudinRP2009–2010 · 2 seasons2005 · 1 season
Aaron SmallRP2005–2006 · 2 seasons1994 · 1 season
Esteban LoaizaRP2004 · 1 season2001–2002 · 2 seasons
Felix HerediaRP2003–2004 · 2 seasons2002 · 1 season
Raul MondesiRF2003 · 1 season2000–2001 · 2 seasons
Alberto CastilloC2002 · 1 season2000–2001 · 2 seasons
Carlos AlmanzarRP2001 · 1 season1997–1998 · 2 seasons
Graeme LloydRP1997–1998 · 2 seasons1999 · 1 season
Doyle AlexanderSP1982 · 1 season1984–1985 · 2 seasons
Dave Collins1B1982 · 1 season1983–1984 · 2 seasons
Paul MirabellaRP1979 · 1 season1980–1981 · 2 seasons
Tom UnderwoodRP1980 · 1 season1978–1979 · 2 seasons
Ali SanchezC2026 · 1 season2025 · 1 season
Joe MantiplyRP2019 · 1 season2026 · 1 season
Jacob BarnesRP2022 · 1 season2025 · 1 season
Jon Berti3B2024 · 1 season2018 · 1 season
Jimmy CorderoRP2023 · 1 season2019 · 1 season
Anthony BandaRP2022 · 1 season2022 · 1 season
Adeiny Hechavarria2B2018 · 1 season2012 · 1 season
Jaime GarciaSP2017 · 1 season2018 · 1 season
Yangervis Solarte3B2014 · 1 season2018 · 1 season
David CarpenterRP2015 · 1 season2012 · 1 season
Jeff FrancisRP2014 · 1 season2015 · 1 season
LaTroy HawkinsRP2008 · 1 season2015 · 1 season
Ben FranciscoLF2013 · 1 season2012 · 1 season
Ryota IgarashiRP2012 · 1 season2012 · 1 season
Octavio DotelRP2006 · 1 season2011 · 1 season
Nick GreenSS2006 · 1 season2010 · 1 season
Dave DellucciLF2003 · 1 season2009 · 1 season
Sal FasanoC2006 · 1 season2007 · 1 season
Cory LidleSP2006 · 1 season2003 · 1 season
Chris LathamCF2003 · 1 season2001 · 1 season
Juan AcevedoRP2003 · 1 season2003 · 1 season
Todd GreeneC2001 · 1 season2000 · 1 season
Mark WhitenCF1997 · 1 season1990 · 1 season
Otis NixonLF1983 · 1 season1996 · 1 season
Xavier HernandezRP1994 · 1 season1989 · 1 season
Juan BeniquezLF1979 · 1 season1988 · 1 season
Don CooperRP1985 · 1 season1983 · 1 season
Mike MorganRP1982 · 1 season1983 · 1 season
Thad WilbornCF1980 · 1 season1979 · 1 season

Regular season, under every name each club has played as. A season split by a trade counts for both clubs where the game logs reach it (NBA from 1993-94, NFL 1994, NHL 1996, MLB 2001). Longest stay with the two first.

New York Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays: head-to-head record →