Players who played for the New York Yankees and St. Louis Cardinals

New York Yankees
St. Louis Cardinals

128 players

128 players have played for both the New York Yankees and the St. Louis Cardinals. Enos Slaughter spent the most seasons with the two: 3 with the New York Yankees and 13 with the St. Louis Cardinals. On a roster now: Paul Goldschmidt, Jordan Montgomery, Luke Weaver, Randal Grichuk, and Sonny Gray. Every season since 1876 is on file.

Players who played for the New York Yankees and the St. Louis Cardinals, with their years at each
PlayerPosNYYSTL
Enos Slaughter—1954–1958 · 3 seasons1938–1953 · 13 seasons
Matt CarpenterDH2022 · 1 season2011–2024 · 12 seasons
Lindy McDanielP1969–1973 · 5 seasons1955–1962 · 8 seasons
Johnny Mize—1950–1953 · 4 seasons1936–1941 · 6 seasons
Giovanny GallegosRP2017–2018 · 2 seasons2018–2024 · 7 seasons
Austin RomineC2011–2019 · 8 seasons2022 · 1 season
Jaime GarciaSP2017 · 1 season2008–2016 · 8 seasons
Matt HollidayOF2017 · 1 season2009–2016 · 8 seasons
Tino Martinez1B1996–2005 · 7 seasons2002–2003 · 2 seasons
Roger Maris—1960–1966 · 7 seasons1967–1968 · 2 seasons
Vic RaschiP1946–1953 · 8 seasons1954 · 1 season
Paul Goldschmidt1B2025–2026 · 2 seasons2019–2024 · 6 seasons
Lance LynnSP2018 · 1 season2011–2024 · 7 seasons
Harrison BaderCF2022–2023 · 2 seasons2017–2022 · 6 seasons
Jordan MontgomerySP2017–2022 · 6 seasons2022–2023 · 2 seasons
Donovan OsborneRP2004 · 1 season1992–1999 · 7 seasons
Pat Kelly2B1991–1997 · 7 seasons1998 · 1 season
Jerry MumphreyLF1981–1982 · 2 seasons1974–1979 · 6 seasons
Billy Johnson—1943–1950 · 6 seasons1952–1953 · 2 seasons
Johnny Hopp—1951 · 1 season1939–1945 · 7 seasons
Brendan RyanSS2013–2015 · 3 seasons2007–2010 · 4 seasons
Randy ChoateRP2000–2003 · 4 seasons2013–2015 · 3 seasons
Sterling HitchcockRP1992–2003 · 6 seasons2003 · 1 season
Todd Zeile1B2003 · 1 season1989–1994 · 6 seasons
Bob TewksburySP1986 · 1 season1989–1994 · 6 seasons
Leo Durocher—1925–1929 · 3 seasons1934–1937 · 4 seasons
Frank Gilhooley—1913–1918 · 6 seasons1912 · 1 season
Luke WeaverRP2023–2025 · 3 seasons2016–2018 · 3 seasons
Luke Voit1B2018–2021 · 4 seasons2017–2018 · 2 seasons
Shane RobinsonLF2018 · 1 season2009–2014 · 5 seasons
Pete KozmaSS2017 · 1 season2011–2015 · 5 seasons
Miguel Cairo1B2004–2007 · 3 seasons2002–2007 · 3 seasons
Dave LaPointSP1989–1990 · 2 seasons1981–1984 · 4 seasons
Jose CruzRF1988 · 1 season1970–1974 · 5 seasons
George FrazierRP1981–1983 · 3 seasons1978–1980 · 3 seasons
Elmer Miller—1915–1921 · 5 seasons1912 · 1 season
Randal GrichukDH2026 · 1 season2014–2017 · 4 seasons
Andrew MillerRP2015–2016 · 2 seasons2019–2021 · 3 seasons
Carlos Ivan BeltranOF2014–2016 · 3 seasons2012–2013 · 2 seasons
Jake WestbrookSP2000 · 1 season2010–2013 · 4 seasons
Joe GirardiC1996–1999 · 4 seasons2003 · 1 season
Mike Gallego2B1992–1994 · 3 seasons1996–1997 · 2 seasons
Lee GuettermanRP1988–1991 · 4 seasons1993 · 1 season
Bob ShirleyRP1983–1986 · 4 seasons1981 · 1 season
Bobby ShantzP1957–1960 · 4 seasons1963 · 1 season
Luis ArroyoP1960–1963 · 4 seasons1955 · 1 season
Irv Noren—1953–1956 · 4 seasons1958 · 1 season
Zinn Beck—1918 · 1 season1913–1916 · 4 seasons
Lee Magee—1916 · 1 season1911–1914 · 4 seasons
Roger Bresnahan—1901 · 1 season1909–1912 · 4 seasons
Adam OttavinoRP2019–2025 · 3 seasons2010 · 1 season
Sonny GraySP2017–2018 · 2 seasons2024–2025 · 2 seasons
Matt BowmanRP2023 · 1 season2016–2018 · 3 seasons
Russ SpringerRP1992 · 1 season2003–2008 · 3 seasons
Allen WatsonRP2000 · 1 season1993–1995 · 3 seasons
Tony FossasRP1999 · 1 season1995–1997 · 3 seasons
John HabyanRP1990–1992 · 3 seasons1994 · 1 season
Rex HudlerRF1984–1985 · 2 seasons1991–1992 · 2 seasons
Jack ClarkDH1988 · 1 season1985–1987 · 3 seasons
Lynn McGlothenRP1982 · 1 season1974–1976 · 3 seasons
Ruben Amaro—1966–1968 · 3 seasons1958 · 1 season
Jack Fournier—1918 · 1 season1920–1922 · 3 seasons
Ambrose PuttmannP1903–1905 · 3 seasons1906 · 1 season
Jack PowellP1904 · 1 season1899–1901 · 3 seasons
Lance BerkmanDH2010 · 1 season2011–2012 · 2 seasons
Ron VilloneRP2006–2007 · 2 seasons2008 · 1 season
Sidney PonsonSP2006–2008 · 2 seasons2006 · 1 season
Randy KeislerRP2000–2001 · 2 seasons2007 · 1 season
Al ReyesRP2003 · 1 season2004–2005 · 2 seasons
Gabe WhiteRP2003–2004 · 2 seasons2005 · 1 season
Juan AcevedoRP2003 · 1 season1998–1999 · 2 seasons
Felix JoseRF2000 · 1 season1991–1992 · 2 seasons
Mark WhitenCF1997 · 1 season1993–1994 · 2 seasons
Alex Johnson—1975 · 1 season1966–1967 · 2 seasons
Danny Cater—1970–1971 · 2 seasons1975 · 1 season
Charley Smith—1967–1968 · 2 seasons1966 · 1 season
Duke Carmel—1965 · 1 season1959–1960 · 2 seasons
Marshall BridgesP1962–1963 · 2 seasons1959 · 1 season
Darrell Johnson—1957–1958 · 2 seasons1960 · 1 season
Al GettelP1945–1946 · 2 seasons1955 · 1 season
Don Bollweg—1953 · 1 season1950–1951 · 2 seasons
Russ Derry—1944–1945 · 2 seasons1949 · 1 season
Frenchy Bordagaray—1941 · 1 season1937–1938 · 2 seasons
Dazzy VanceP1915–1918 · 2 seasons1933 · 1 season
Jimmie Reese—1930–1931 · 2 seasons1932 · 1 season
Hank RobinsonP1918 · 1 season1914–1915 · 2 seasons
Cozy Dolan—1911 · 1 season1914–1915 · 2 seasons
Lou Criger—1910 · 1 season1899–1900 · 2 seasons
Billy Gilbert—1902 · 1 season1908–1909 · 2 seasons
Champ Osteen—1904 · 1 season1908–1909 · 2 seasons
Wilbert Robinson—1901–1902 · 2 seasons1900 · 1 season
Mike Donlin—1901 · 1 season1899–1900 · 2 seasons
Ali SanchezC2026 · 1 season2021 · 1 season
Caleb FergusonRP2024 · 1 season2026 · 1 season
Jacob BarnesRP2022 · 1 season2023 · 1 season
Chad Huffman1B2010 · 1 season2017 · 1 season
Dean AnnaSS2014 · 1 season2015 · 1 season
Mark Reynolds1B2013 · 1 season2015 · 1 season
Octavio DotelRP2006 · 1 season2011 · 1 season
Raul ValdesRP2011 · 1 season2011 · 1 season
Randy WinnLF2010 · 1 season2010 · 1 season
Brett TomkoSP2009 · 1 season2003 · 1 season
Josh Phelps1B2007 · 1 season2008 · 1 season
Kelly StinnettC2006 · 1 season2007 · 1 season
Jeff WeaverRP2003 · 1 season2006 · 1 season
Scott Seabol3B2001 · 1 season2005 · 1 season
Tony Womack2B2005 · 1 season2004 · 1 season
Jesse OroscoRP2003 · 1 season2000 · 1 season
Alberto CastilloC2002 · 1 season1999 · 1 season
Ivan Cruz1B1997 · 1 season2002 · 1 season
Lance JohnsonDH2000 · 1 season1987 · 1 season
Dave Collins1B1982 · 1 season1990 · 1 season
Neil AllenRP1988 · 1 season1984 · 1 season
Rafael SantanaSS1988 · 1 season1983 · 1 season
Ivan DeJesusSS1986 · 1 season1985 · 1 season
Bobby BondsCF1975 · 1 season1980 · 1 season
Al CicotteP1957 · 1 season1961 · 1 season
Buster Mills—1940 · 1 season1934 · 1 season
Gabby Street—1912 · 1 season1931 · 1 season
Ham Hyatt—1918 · 1 season1915 · 1 season
Paddy O'connor—1918 · 1 season1914 · 1 season
Joe McCarthy—1905 · 1 season1906 · 1 season
Joe Connor—1905 · 1 season1895 · 1 season
Jack O'connor—1903 · 1 season1899 · 1 season
Pat McCauley—1903 · 1 season1893 · 1 season
Bill Keister—1901 · 1 season1900 · 1 season
John McGraw—1901 · 1 season1900 · 1 season
Steve Brodie—1901 · 1 season1892 · 1 season

Regular season, under every name each club has played as. A season split by a trade counts for both clubs where the game logs reach it (NBA from 1993-94, NFL 1994, NHL 1996, MLB 2001). Longest stay with the two first.

New York Yankees vs St. Louis Cardinals: head-to-head record →