New York Yankees All-Stars

148 players

148 players were All-Stars in a season with the New York Yankees. Mickey Mantle did it the most, 16 times (1952–1965, 1967–1968). On a roster now: Aaron Judge, Gerrit Cole, Aroldis Chapman, Clay Holmes, and Gary Sanchez.

New York Yankees All-Stars
Player	Pos	Seasons	Times
Mickey Mantle	—	1952–1965, 1967–1968	16
Yogi Berra	—	1948–1962	15
Derek Jeter	SS	1998–2002, 2004, 2006–2012, 2014	14
Mariano Rivera	RP	1997, 1999–2002, 2004–2006, 2008–2011, 2013	13
Joe DiMaggio	—	1936–1942, 1946–1951	13
Bill Dickey	—	1933–1934, 1936–1943, 1946	11
Elston Howard	—	1957–1965	9
Aaron Judge	RF	2017–2018, 2021–2026	8
Dave Winfield	DH	1981–1988	8
Whitey Ford	P	1954–1956, 1958–1961, 1964	8
Alex Rodriguez	DH	2004–2008, 2010–2011	7
Thurman Munson	—	1971, 1973–1978	7
Bobby Richardson	—	1957, 1959, 1962–1966	7
Lefty Gomez	P	1933–1939	7
Lou Gehrig	—	1933–1939	7
Don Mattingly	1B	1984–1989	6
Joe Gordon	—	1939–1943, 1946	6
Red Ruffing	P	1934, 1938–1942	6
Robinson Cano	2B	2006, 2010–2013	5
Jorge Posada	DH	2000–2003, 2007	5
Bernie Williams	RF	1997–2001	5
Willie Randolph	2B	1976–1977, 1980–1981, 1987	5
Reggie Jackson	DH	1977–1981	5
Graig Nettles	3B	1975, 1977–1980	5
Mel Stottlemyre	P	1965–1966, 1968–1970	5
Bill Skowron	—	1957–1961	5
Gil McDougald	—	1952, 1956–1959	5
Allie Reynolds	P	1949–1950, 1952–1954	5
Phil Rizzuto	—	1942, 1950–1953	5
Tommy Henrich	—	1942, 1947–1950	5
Charlie Keller	—	1940–1941, 1943, 1946–1947	5
Dellin Betances	RP	2014–2017	4
Paul O'Neill	RF	1994–1995, 1997–1998	4
Wade Boggs	3B	1993–1996	4
Rickey Henderson	LF	1985–1988	4
Ron Guidry	SP	1978–1979, 1982–1983	4
Rich Gossage	—	1978, 1980–1982	4
Bobby Murcer	DH	1971–1974	4
Vic Raschi	P	1948–1950, 1952	4
Spud Chandler	P	1942–1943, 1946–1947	4
Red Rolfe	—	1937–1940	4
Gerrit Cole	SP	2021–2023	3
Aroldis Chapman	RP	2018–2019, 2021	3
CC Sabathia	SP	2010–2012	3
Andy Pettitte	SP	1996, 2001, 2010	3
Jason Giambi	DH	2002–2004	3
Sparky Lyle	RP	1973, 1976–1977	3
Joe Pepitone	—	1963–1965	3
Roger Maris	—	1960–1962	3
Tony Kubek	—	1958–1959, 1961	3
Hank Bauer	—	1952–1954	3
Joe Page	P	1944, 1947–1948	3
Johnny Murphy	P	1937–1939	3
Ben Chapman	—	1933–1935	3
Clay Holmes	SP	2022, 2024	2
Gary Sanchez	C	2017, 2019	2
Gleyber Torres	2B	2018–2019	2
Masahiro Tanaka	SP	2014, 2019	2
Luis Severino	SP	2017–2018	2
Mark Teixeira	1B	2009, 2015	2
Curtis Granderson	LF	2011–2012	2
Gary Sheffield	LF	2004–2005	2
Hideki Matsui	LF	2003–2004	2
Alfonso Soriano	RF	2002–2003	2
Roger Clemens	SP	2001, 2003	2
David Cone	SP	1997, 1999	2
Jimmy Key	RP	1993–1994	2
Steve Sax	2B	1989–1990	2
Dave Righetti	SP	1986–1987	2
Bucky Dent	SS	1980–1981	2
Tommy John	SP	1979–1980	2
Catfish Hunter	P	1975–1976	2
Roy White	—	1969–1970	2
Tom Tresh	—	1962–1963	2
Ryne Duren	P	1958–1959	2
Bob Turley	P	1955, 1958	2
George McQuinn	—	1947–1948	2
Tiny Bonham	P	1942–1943	2
Monte Pearson	P	1936, 1940	2
Frankie Crosetti	—	1936, 1939	2
George Selkirk	—	1936, 1939	2
Babe Ruth	—	1933–1934	2
Ben Rice	DH	2026	1
Cam Schlittler	SP	2026	1
Cody Bellinger	LF	2026	1
Carlos Rodon	SP	2025	1
Jazz Chisholm Jr.	2B	2025	1
Max Fried	SP	2025	1
Juan Soto	LF	2024	1
Andrew Benintendi	DH	2022	1
Giancarlo Stanton	DH	2022	1
Jose Trevino	C	2022	1
Nestor Cortes	SP	2022	1
Joey Gallo	1B	2021	1
DJ LeMahieu	2B	2019	1
J.A. Happ	SP	2018	1
Starlin Castro	3B	2017	1
Andrew Miller	RP	2016	1
Carlos Beltrán	—	2016	1
Brett Gardner	CF	2015	1
David Robertson	RP	2011	1
Russell Martin	C	2011	1
Nick Swisher	LF	2010	1
Phil Hughes	RP	2010	1
Esteban Loaiza	RP	2004	1
Javier Vazquez	SP	2004	1
Tom Gordon	RP	2004	1
Aaron Boone	3B	2003	1
Robin Ventura	1B	2002	1
Mike Stanton	RP	2001	1
David Wells	SP	1998	1
Scott Brosius	3B	1998	1
Tino Martinez	1B	1997	1
John Wetteland	RP	1996	1
Mike Stanley	1B	1995	1
Roberto Kelly	LF	1992	1
Scott Sanderson	SP	1991	1
Phil Niekro	SP	1984	1
Ron Davis	RP	1981	1
Chris Chambliss	1B	1976	1
Mickey Rivers	DH	1976	1
Bobby Bonds	CF	1975	1
Fritz Peterson	P	1970	1
Al Downing	P	1967	1
Jim Bouton	P	1963	1
Ralph Terry	P	1962	1
Luis Arroyo	P	1961	1
Jim Coates	P	1960	1
Bobby Shantz	P	1957	1
Bob Grim	P	1957	1
Billy Martin	—	1956	1
Johnny Kucks	P	1956	1
Irv Noren	—	1954	1
Johnny Mize	—	1953	1
Johnny Sain	P	1953	1
Ed Lopat	P	1951	1
Jerry Coleman	—	1950	1
Tommy Byrne	P	1950	1
Aaron Robinson	—	1947	1
Billy Johnson	—	1947	1
Spec Shea	P	1947	1
Snuffy Stirnweiss	—	1946	1
Hank Borowy	P	1944	1
Rollie Hemsley	—	1944	1
Johnny Lindell	P	1943	1
Buddy Rosar	—	1942	1
Marius Russo	P	1941	1
Tony Lazzeri	—	1933	1

Show all 148 players

Selections from MLB's own records, under the club each player represented. Every season since 1876 is on file. A season split between two clubs is filed as one combined line and counts for neither.

New York Yankees: roster, record and every grid cell →