Players who played for the New York Mets and Toronto Blue Jays

New York Mets
Toronto Blue Jays

100 players

100 players have played for both the New York Mets and the Toronto Blue Jays. Carlos Delgado spent the most seasons with the two: 4 with the New York Mets and 12 with the Toronto Blue Jays. On a roster now: Bo Bichette, Steven Matz, Paul Sewald, Anthony Kay, and Max Scherzer. Every season since 1876 is on file.

Players who played for the New York Mets and the Toronto Blue Jays, with their years at each
PlayerPosNYMTOR
Carlos Delgado1B2006–2009 · 4 seasons1993–2004 · 12 seasons
Jose ReyesSS2003–2018 · 12 seasons2013–2015 · 3 seasons
Al LeiterSP1998–2004 · 7 seasons1990–1995 · 6 seasons
Jose BautistaRF2018 · 1 season2008–2017 · 10 seasons
John Olerud1B1997–1999 · 3 seasons1989–1996 · 8 seasons
Mookie WilsonLF1980–1988 · 9 seasons1990–1991 · 2 seasons
Chris Woodward1B2005–2006 · 2 seasons1999–2011 · 7 seasons
Shawn GreenRF2006–2007 · 2 seasons1993–1999 · 7 seasons
Edgardo Alfonzo3B1995–2002 · 8 seasons2006 · 1 season
Bo Bichette3B2026 · 1 season2019–2025 · 7 seasons
Aaron LoupRP2021 · 1 season2012–2018 · 7 seasons
Kevin PillarCF2021 · 1 season2013–2019 · 7 seasons
Marcus StromanSP2019–2021 · 2 seasons2014–2019 · 6 seasons
Josh TholeC2009–2012 · 4 seasons2013–2016 · 4 seasons
Roy Lee JacksonRP1977–1980 · 4 seasons1981–1984 · 4 seasons
Steven MatzSP2015–2020 · 6 seasons2021 · 1 season
R.A. DickeySP2010–2012 · 3 seasons2013–2016 · 4 seasons
Roberto Alomar2B2002–2003 · 2 seasons1991–1995 · 5 seasons
Bob Bailor3B1981–1983 · 3 seasons1977–1980 · 4 seasons
Shaun MarcumSP2013 · 1 season2005–2010 · 5 seasons
Jason PhillipsC2001–2004 · 4 seasons2006–2007 · 2 seasons
Alberto CastilloC1995–1998 · 4 seasons2000–2001 · 2 seasons
Paul SewaldRP2017–2020 · 4 seasons2026 · 1 season
Justin Turner1B2010–2013 · 4 seasons2024 · 1 season
Anthony KaySP2023 · 1 season2019–2022 · 4 seasons
Curtis GrandersonLF2014–2017 · 4 seasons2018 · 1 season
Frank CatalanottoLF2010 · 1 season2003–2006 · 4 seasons
Armando BenitezRP1999–2002 · 4 seasons2008 · 1 season
Pete WalkerRP1995–2001 · 2 seasons2003–2006 · 3 seasons
David WeathersRP2002–2004 · 3 seasons1991–1992 · 2 seasons
Charlie O'BrienC1991–1993 · 3 seasons1996–1997 · 2 seasons
Max ScherzerSP2022–2023 · 2 seasons2025–2026 · 2 seasons
Chris BassittSP2022 · 1 season2023–2025 · 3 seasons
Brandon Drury2B2021 · 1 season2018–2020 · 3 seasons
Rajai DavisCF2019 · 1 season2011–2013 · 3 seasons
Kelly Johnson2B2015–2016 · 2 seasons2011–2012 · 2 seasons
Brandon LyonRP2013 · 1 season2001–2012 · 3 seasons
Miguel BatistaSP2011–2012 · 2 seasons2004–2005 · 2 seasons
Marco Scutaro2B2002–2003 · 2 seasons2008–2009 · 2 seasons
Scott SchoeneweisRP2007–2008 · 2 seasons2005–2006 · 2 seasons
Victor ZambranoSP2004–2006 · 3 seasons2007 · 1 season
Robert PersonRP1995–1996 · 2 seasons1997–1998 · 2 seasons
Bob MacDonaldRP1996 · 1 season1990–1992 · 3 seasons
Rick CeroneC1991 · 1 season1977–1979 · 3 seasons
Jeff MusselmanRP1990 · 1 season1986–1988 · 3 seasons
Lou ThorntonCF1989 · 1 season1985–1988 · 3 seasons
Jackson ToddSP1977 · 1 season1979–1981 · 3 seasons
Andres GimenezSS2020 · 1 season2025–2026 · 2 seasons
Richard LoveladyRP2025–2026 · 2 seasons2025 · 1 season
Genesis CabreraRP2025 · 1 season2023–2024 · 2 seasons
Josh WalkerRP2023–2024 · 2 seasons2025 · 1 season
Taijuan WalkerSP2021–2022 · 2 seasons2020 · 1 season
Wilmer FontRP2019 · 1 season2019–2020 · 2 seasons
Darrell CecilianiCF2015 · 1 season2016–2017 · 2 seasons
Joe SmithRP2007–2008 · 2 seasons2017 · 1 season
Aaron LaffeySP2013 · 1 season2012–2013 · 2 seasons
Darren OliverRP2006 · 1 season2012–2013 · 2 seasons
Frank FranciscoRP2012–2013 · 2 seasons2011 · 1 season
Ryota IgarashiRP2010–2011 · 2 seasons2012 · 1 season
Rod BarajasC2010 · 1 season2008–2009 · 2 seasons
Jorge VelandiaSS2001–2003 · 2 seasons2008 · 1 season
Tom WilsonC2004 · 1 season2002–2003 · 2 seasons
Doug LintonRP1994 · 1 season1992–2003 · 2 seasons
Jeff TamRP1998–1999 · 2 seasons2003 · 1 season
Derek BellRF2000 · 1 season1991–1992 · 2 seasons
Frank ViolaSP1990–1991 · 2 seasons1996 · 1 season
Mauro GozzoRP1993–1994 · 2 seasons1989 · 1 season
Mark BombackSP1980 · 1 season1981–1982 · 2 seasons
Marcus Semien2B2026 · 1 season2021 · 1 season
Tyler RogersRP2025 · 1 season2026 · 1 season
Ali SanchezC2020 · 1 season2025 · 1 season
Jose UrenaRP2025 · 1 season2025 · 1 season
Jonathan VillarSS2021 · 1 season2020 · 1 season
Tommy MiloneSP2017 · 1 season2021 · 1 season
Adeiny Hechavarria2B2019 · 1 season2012 · 1 season
Neil RamirezRP2017 · 1 season2019 · 1 season
Tyler ClippardRP2015 · 1 season2018 · 1 season
Norichika AokiRF2017 · 1 season2017 · 1 season
John Mayberry Jr.LF2015 · 1 season2014 · 1 season
LaTroy HawkinsRP2013 · 1 season2015 · 1 season
Dana EvelandRP2014 · 1 season2010 · 1 season
Henry BlancoC2010 · 1 season2013 · 1 season
John BuckC2013 · 1 season2010 · 1 season
Fred LewisOF2012 · 1 season2010 · 1 season
Jon RauchRP2012 · 1 season2011 · 1 season
Octavio DotelRP1999 · 1 season2011 · 1 season
Taylor BuchholzRP2011 · 1 season2010 · 1 season
Jeremy T ReedLF2009 · 1 season2010 · 1 season
Felix HerediaRP2005 · 1 season2002 · 1 season
Miguel Cairo1B2005 · 1 season1996 · 1 season
Cory LidleSP1997 · 1 season2003 · 1 season
Graeme LloydRP2003 · 1 season1999 · 1 season
Juan AcevedoRP1997 · 1 season2003 · 1 season
Charlie GreeneC1996 · 1 season2000 · 1 season
Eric GundersonRP1994 · 1 season2000 · 1 season
Brian BohanonSP1997 · 1 season1996 · 1 season
Ricardo JordanRP1997 · 1 season1995 · 1 season
Rick TrlicekRP1996 · 1 season1992 · 1 season
Mickey WestonRP1993 · 1 season1991 · 1 season
Tom FilerRP1992 · 1 season1985 · 1 season

Regular season, under every name each club has played as. A season split by a trade counts for both clubs where the game logs reach it (NBA from 1993-94, NFL 1994, NHL 1996, MLB 2001). Longest stay with the two first.

New York Mets vs Toronto Blue Jays: head-to-head record →