Players who played for the Cleveland Guardians and Toronto Blue Jays
83 players
83 players have played for both the Cleveland Guardians and the Toronto Blue Jays. John McDonald spent the most seasons with the two: 7 with the Cleveland Guardians and 7 with the Toronto Blue Jays. On a roster now: Andres Gimenez, Ernie Clement, Myles Straw, Luke Maile, and Foster Griffin. Every season since 1876 is on file.
| Player | Pos | CLE | TOR |
|---|---|---|---|
| John McDonald | 3B | 1999–2013 · 7 seasons | 2005–2011 · 7 seasons |
| Joe Carter | 1B | 1984–1989 · 6 seasons | 1991–1997 · 7 seasons |
| Omar Vizquel | 2B | 1994–2004 · 11 seasons | 2012 · 1 season |
| Tony Fernandez | DH | 1997 · 1 season | 1983–1999 · 10 seasons |
| Alfredo Griffin | SS | 1976–1978 · 3 seasons | 1979–1993 · 8 seasons |
| Edwin Encarnacion | DH | 2017–2018 · 2 seasons | 2009–2016 · 8 seasons |
| Willie Upshaw | 1B | 1988 · 1 season | 1978–1987 · 9 seasons |
| Shane Bieber | SP | 2018–2024 · 7 seasons | 2025–2026 · 2 seasons |
| Brian Tallet | RP | 2002–2005 · 3 seasons | 2006–2011 · 6 seasons |
| Pat Borders | C | 1997–1998 · 2 seasons | 1988–1994 · 7 seasons |
| Roberto Alomar | 2B | 1999–2001 · 3 seasons | 1991–1995 · 5 seasons |
| Marc Rzepczynski | RP | 2013–2018 · 4 seasons | 2009–2011 · 3 seasons |
| Yan Gomes | C | 2013–2018 · 6 seasons | 2012 · 1 season |
| Joe Smith | RP | 2009–2017 · 6 seasons | 2017 · 1 season |
| Pat Tabler | DH | 1983–1987 · 5 seasons | 1991–1992 · 2 seasons |
| Otto Velez | DH | 1983 · 1 season | 1977–1982 · 6 seasons |
| Andres Gimenez | SS | 2021–2024 · 4 seasons | 2025–2026 · 2 seasons |
| Ernie Clement | 2B | 2021–2022 · 2 seasons | 2023–2026 · 4 seasons |
| Ezequiel Carrera | LF | 2011–2013 · 3 seasons | 2015–2017 · 3 seasons |
| Shaun Marcum | SP | 2015 · 1 season | 2005–2010 · 5 seasons |
| Aaron Laffey | SP | 2007–2010 · 4 seasons | 2012–2013 · 2 seasons |
| Jeremy Accardo | RP | 2012 · 1 season | 2006–2010 · 5 seasons |
| Josh Phelps | 1B | 2004 · 1 season | 2000–2004 · 5 seasons |
| Frank Wills | RP | 1986–1987 · 2 seasons | 1988–1991 · 4 seasons |
| Tom Buskey | RP | 1975–1977 · 3 seasons | 1978–1980 · 3 seasons |
| Alan Ashby | C | 1973–1976 · 4 seasons | 1977–1978 · 2 seasons |
| Myles Straw | CF | 2022–2024 · 3 seasons | 2025–2026 · 2 seasons |
| Josh Donaldson | 3B | 2018 · 1 season | 2015–2018 · 4 seasons |
| Rajai Davis | CF | 2016–2018 · 2 seasons | 2011–2013 · 3 seasons |
| Vinnie Chulk | RP | 2009 · 1 season | 2003–2006 · 4 seasons |
| Mark Whiten | CF | 1992–2000 · 4 seasons | 1990 · 1 season |
| Otis Nixon | LF | 1984–1987 · 4 seasons | 1996 · 1 season |
| Rick Cerone | C | 1975–1976 · 2 seasons | 1977–1979 · 3 seasons |
| Rico Carty | — | 1974–1977 · 4 seasons | 1979 · 1 season |
| Luke Maile | C | 2022 · 1 season | 2017–2019 · 3 seasons |
| Ben Francisco | LF | 2007–2009 · 3 seasons | 2012 · 1 season |
| Dave Dellucci | LF | 2007–2009 · 3 seasons | 2009 · 1 season |
| Joe Inglett | 2B | 2006 · 1 season | 2007–2009 · 3 seasons |
| Justin Speier | RP | 2000 · 1 season | 2004–2006 · 3 seasons |
| Ken Schrom | SP | 1986–1987 · 2 seasons | 1980–1982 · 2 seasons |
| A.J. Cole | RP | 2019 · 1 season | 2020–2021 · 2 seasons |
| Neil Ramirez | RP | 2018–2019 · 2 seasons | 2019 · 1 season |
| Gio Urshela | 3B | 2015–2017 · 2 seasons | 2018 · 1 season |
| Melky Cabrera | RF | 2018 · 1 season | 2013–2014 · 2 seasons |
| Esmil Rogers | RP | 2012 · 1 season | 2013–2014 · 2 seasons |
| Justin Germano | RP | 2010–2011 · 2 seasons | 2013 · 1 season |
| Hector Luna | 1B | 2006 · 1 season | 2007–2008 · 2 seasons |
| Candy Maldonado | LF | 1990–1994 · 2 seasons | 1992 · 1 season |
| Jack Morris | SP | 1994 · 1 season | 1992–1993 · 2 seasons |
| Turner Ward | RF | 1990 · 1 season | 1992–1993 · 2 seasons |
| Glenallen Hill | DH | 1992 · 1 season | 1989–1990 · 2 seasons |
| Mauro Gozzo | RP | 1990–1991 · 2 seasons | 1989 · 1 season |
| Mitch Webster | LF | 1990 · 1 season | 1983–1984 · 2 seasons |
| Steve Davis | RP | 1989 · 1 season | 1985–1986 · 2 seasons |
| Jorge Orta | DH | 1980–1981 · 2 seasons | 1983 · 1 season |
| Ted Cox | 3B | 1978–1979 · 2 seasons | 1981 · 1 season |
| Victor Cruz | RP | 1979–1980 · 2 seasons | 1978 · 1 season |
| Foster Griffin | SP | 2026 · 1 season | 2022 · 1 season |
| Paul Sewald | RP | 2025 · 1 season | 2026 · 1 season |
| Matthew Boyd | SP | 2024 · 1 season | 2015 · 1 season |
| Tyler Clippard | RP | 2019 · 1 season | 2018 · 1 season |
| John Axford | RP | 2014 · 1 season | 2018 · 1 season |
| Oliver Drake | RP | 2018 · 1 season | 2018 · 1 season |
| Preston Guilmet | RP | 2013 · 1 season | 2018 · 1 season |
| Gavin Floyd | RP | 2015 · 1 season | 2016 · 1 season |
| Mark Lowe | RP | 2014 · 1 season | 2015 · 1 season |
| George Kottaras | C | 2014 · 1 season | 2014 · 1 season |
| Mark DeRosa | 2B | 2009 · 1 season | 2013 · 1 season |
| Jayson Nix | SS | 2010 · 1 season | 2011 · 1 season |
| Bryan Bullington | RP | 2008 · 1 season | 2009 · 1 season |
| Jorge Velandia | SS | 2008 · 1 season | 2008 · 1 season |
| Sal Fasano | C | 2008 · 1 season | 2007 · 1 season |
| Chris Gomez | 3B | 2007 · 1 season | 2004 · 1 season |
| Dave Maurer | P | 2002 · 1 season | 2004 · 1 season |
| Dave Hollins | 1B | 2001 · 1 season | 1999 · 1 season |
| Marty Cordova | LF | 2001 · 1 season | 2000 · 1 season |
| Dave Winfield | DH | 1995 · 1 season | 1992 · 1 season |
| Lance Parrish | C | 1993 · 1 season | 1995 · 1 season |
| Rene Gonzales | 3B | 1994 · 1 season | 1991 · 1 season |
| Willie Blair | RP | 1991 · 1 season | 1990 · 1 season |
| Don Gordon | RP | 1988 · 1 season | 1986 · 1 season |
| Bryan Clark | RP | 1985 · 1 season | 1984 · 1 season |
| Jerry Johnson | RP | 1973 · 1 season | 1977 · 1 season |
Regular season, under every name each club has played as. A season split by a trade counts for both clubs where the game logs reach it (NBA from 1993-94, NFL 1994, NHL 1996, MLB 2001). Longest stay with the two first.
Cleveland Guardians vs Toronto Blue Jays: head-to-head record →