Players who played for the Cleveland Guardians and Pittsburgh Pirates

Cleveland Guardians
Pittsburgh Pirates

145 players

145 players have played for both the Cleveland Guardians and the Pittsburgh Pirates. Terry Turner spent the most seasons with the two: 15 with the Cleveland Guardians and 1 with the Pittsburgh Pirates. On a roster now: Austin Hedges, Josh Bell, and Yohan Ramirez. Every season since 1876 is on file.

Players who played for the Cleveland Guardians and the Pittsburgh Pirates, with their years at each
PlayerPosCLEPIT
Terry Turner—1904–1918 · 15 seasons1901 · 1 season
Carlos Santana1B2010–2025 · 11 seasons2023 · 1 season
Sam McDowellP1961–1971 · 11 seasons1975 · 1 season
Kenny LoftonLF1992–2007 · 10 seasons2003 · 1 season
Jay Bell2B1986–1988 · 3 seasons1989–1996 · 8 seasons
Brian GilesRF1995–1998 · 4 seasons1999–2003 · 5 seasons
George Strickland—1953–1960 · 7 seasons1950–1951 · 2 seasons
Doc Johnston—1912–1921 · 7 seasons1915–1916 · 2 seasons
Oliver PerezRP2018–2021 · 4 seasons2003–2006 · 4 seasons
John McDonald3B1999–2013 · 7 seasons2013 · 1 season
Junior OrtizC1992–1993 · 2 seasons1982–1989 · 6 seasons
Miguel DiloneCF1980–1983 · 4 seasons1974–1977 · 4 seasons
Ralph Kiner—1955 · 1 season1946–1952 · 7 seasons
Homer Summa—1922–1928 · 7 seasons1920 · 1 season
Jim BagbyP1916–1922 · 7 seasons1923 · 1 season
Bill Hinchman—1907–1909 · 3 seasons1915–1920 · 5 seasons
Austin HedgesC2020–2026 · 6 seasons2023 · 1 season
Jason DavisSP2002–2007 · 6 seasons2008 · 1 season
Scott SauerbeckRP2005–2006 · 2 seasons1999–2003 · 5 seasons
Jose MesaRP1993–1997 · 5 seasons2004–2005 · 2 seasons
Felix Fermin2B1989–1993 · 5 seasons1987–1988 · 2 seasons
Neal HeatonRP1982–1985 · 4 seasons1989–1991 · 3 seasons
Bert BlylevenSP1981–1984 · 4 seasons1978–1980 · 3 seasons
Jim BibbyRP1976–1977 · 2 seasons1978–1983 · 5 seasons
Luis TiantSP1964–1969 · 6 seasons1981 · 1 season
Vic Davalillo1B1963–1967 · 5 seasons1971–1972 · 2 seasons
Al Lopez—1947 · 1 season1941–1946 · 6 seasons
Rollie Hemsley—1938–1941 · 4 seasons1928–1930 · 3 seasons
Sherry SmithP1923–1927 · 5 seasons1911–1912 · 2 seasons
Fred Carisch—1912–1914 · 3 seasons1903–1906 · 4 seasons
Josh BellDH2023 · 1 season2016–2020 · 5 seasons
Tom GorzelannyRP2016 · 1 season2005–2009 · 5 seasons
Paul WagnerRP1999 · 1 season1992–1996 · 5 seasons
Cecilio GuanteRP1990 · 1 season1982–1986 · 5 seasons
Ernie CamachoRP1983–1987 · 5 seasons1981 · 1 season
Cal McLishP1956–1959 · 4 seasons1947–1948 · 2 seasons
Wally Westlake—1953–1954 · 2 seasons1947–1950 · 4 seasons
Les Fleming—1941–1947 · 5 seasons1949 · 1 season
Jim BagbyP1941–1945 · 5 seasons1947 · 1 season
Nig Clarke—1906–1910 · 5 seasons1920 · 1 season
Colin HoldermanRP2026 · 1 season2022–2025 · 4 seasons
Yohan RamirezRP2022 · 1 season2022–2026 · 4 seasons
Greg AllenCF2017–2020 · 4 seasons2022 · 1 season
Jeanmar GomezRP2010–2012 · 3 seasons2013–2014 · 2 seasons
Tim LakerC2001–2006 · 4 seasons1999 · 1 season
Dan MiceliRP2003 · 1 season1993–1996 · 4 seasons
Julian TavarezRP1993–1996 · 4 seasons2003 · 1 season
Ricardo RinconRP1999–2001 · 3 seasons1997–1998 · 2 seasons
Mike BieleckiRP1993 · 1 season1984–1987 · 4 seasons
Denny Gonzalez3B1989 · 1 season1984–1988 · 4 seasons
Hank Foiles—1955 · 1 season1956–1959 · 4 seasons
Gene Woodling—1943–1957 · 4 seasons1947 · 1 season
Ken JungelsP1937–1941 · 4 seasons1942 · 1 season
Roy Spencer—1933–1934 · 2 seasons1925–1927 · 3 seasons
Walter Barbare—1914–1916 · 3 seasons1919–1920 · 2 seasons
Cy FalkenbergP1909–1913 · 4 seasons1903 · 1 season
Rajai DavisCF2016–2018 · 2 seasons2006–2007 · 2 seasons
Michael Martinez2B2015–2017 · 3 seasons2014 · 1 season
Brandon MossRF2015 · 1 season2008–2010 · 3 seasons
Nyjer MorganCF2014 · 1 season2007–2009 · 3 seasons
Ryan LudwickLF2003–2005 · 3 seasons2011 · 1 season
Jason MichaelsLF2006–2008 · 3 seasons2008 · 1 season
Jose Hernandez1B1992–2005 · 2 seasons2003–2006 · 2 seasons
Jody GerutCF2003–2005 · 3 seasons2005 · 1 season
Rick WhiteRP2004 · 1 season1994–2005 · 3 seasons
Doug FrobelDH1987 · 1 season1982–1984 · 3 seasons
Jerry DybzinskiSS1980–1982 · 3 seasons1985 · 1 season
Bob JohnsonP1974 · 1 season1971–1973 · 3 seasons
Rocky Nelson—1954 · 1 season1959–1961 · 3 seasons
Ray PoatP1942–1944 · 3 seasons1949 · 1 season
George Susce—1942–1944 · 3 seasons1939 · 1 season
Eddie Moore—1934 · 1 season1923–1925 · 3 seasons
George GrantP1927–1929 · 3 seasons1931 · 1 season
Jimmy ZinnP1929 · 1 season1920–1922 · 3 seasons
Joe DawsonP1924 · 1 season1927–1929 · 3 seasons
Cliff Lee—1925–1926 · 2 seasons1919–1920 · 2 seasons
Billy Southworth—1915 · 1 season1918–1920 · 3 seasons
Syd Smith—1910–1911 · 2 seasons1914–1915 · 2 seasons
Jack McCarthy—1901–1902 · 2 seasons1898–1899 · 2 seasons
George KontosRP2018 · 1 season2017–2018 · 2 seasons
Ramon VazquezSS2005–2006 · 2 seasons2009 · 1 season
Bryan BullingtonRP2008 · 1 season2005–2007 · 2 seasons
Jason BoydRP2003 · 1 season1999–2004 · 2 seasons
Jason C. PhillipsRP2002–2003 · 2 seasons1999 · 1 season
Turner WardRF1990 · 1 season1997–1998 · 2 seasons
Dave OttoRP1991–1992 · 2 seasons1993 · 1 season
Ed WhitsonSP1982 · 1 season1977–1978 · 2 seasons
Gary Alexander1B1979–1980 · 2 seasons1981 · 1 season
Kurt Bevacqua3B1971–1972 · 2 seasons1981 · 1 season
Victor CruzRP1979–1980 · 2 seasons1981 · 1 season
Johnny Jeter—1974 · 1 season1969–1970 · 2 seasons
Mickey Vernon—1949–1958 · 2 seasons1960 · 1 season
Preston Ward—1957 · 1 season1954–1955 · 2 seasons
Catfish Metkovich—1947 · 1 season1951–1952 · 2 seasons
Eddie Bockman—1947 · 1 season1948–1949 · 2 seasons
Billy Sullivan—1936–1937 · 2 seasons1947 · 1 season
Bill Brenzel—1934–1935 · 2 seasons1932 · 1 season
Joe Harris—1917–1919 · 2 seasons1927 · 1 season
Stuffy McInnis—1922 · 1 season1925–1926 · 2 seasons
George McQuillanP1918 · 1 season1913–1914 · 2 seasons
Bob Coleman—1916 · 1 season1913–1914 · 2 seasons
Roy Wood—1914–1915 · 2 seasons1913 · 1 season
Bill HartP1901 · 1 season1895–1898 · 2 seasons
Cody BoltonSP2025 · 1 season2023 · 1 season
Rich HillSP2013 · 1 season2023 · 1 season
Ryan LavarnwayC2021 · 1 season2018 · 1 season
JB ShuckLF2014 · 1 season2019 · 1 season
Melky CabreraRF2018 · 1 season2019 · 1 season
Marlon ByrdRF2016 · 1 season2013 · 1 season
Jayson NixSS2010 · 1 season2014 · 1 season
John AxfordRP2014 · 1 season2014 · 1 season
Joe MartinezRP2013 · 1 season2010 · 1 season
Drew SuttonSS2010 · 1 season2012 · 1 season
Jose VerasRP2009 · 1 season2011 · 1 season
Wyatt ToregasC2009 · 1 season2011 · 1 season
Brendan DonnellyRP2008 · 1 season2010 · 1 season
Chris Gomez3B2007 · 1 season2008 · 1 season
Luis RivasSS2007 · 1 season2008 · 1 season
Josh Phelps1B2004 · 1 season2007 · 1 season
Roberto HernandezRP2007 · 1 season2006 · 1 season
Jason JohnsonSP2006 · 1 season1997 · 1 season
Jeromy BurnitzRF1995 · 1 season2006 · 1 season
Sean Casey1B1997 · 1 season2006 · 1 season
Jeff C. D'AmicoSP2004 · 1 season2003 · 1 season
Ron VilloneRP1998 · 1 season2002 · 1 season
Lance ParrishC1993 · 1 season1994 · 1 season
Ted PowerP1992 · 1 season1990 · 1 season
Mike YorkRP1991 · 1 season1990 · 1 season
Houston Jimenez2B1988 · 1 season1987 · 1 season
Bob OwchinkoSP1980 · 1 season1983 · 1 season
Del Crandall—1966 · 1 season1965 · 1 season
Chuck ChurnP1958 · 1 season1957 · 1 season
Pete Reiser—1952 · 1 season1951 · 1 season
Frank PapishP1949 · 1 season1950 · 1 season
Wally Judnich—1948 · 1 season1949 · 1 season
Jimmy Wasdell—1947 · 1 season1942 · 1 season
Eddie Phillips—1935 · 1 season1931 · 1 season
Jesse PettyP1921 · 1 season1929 · 1 season
Johnny MiljusP1929 · 1 season1927 · 1 season
Jack Farmer—1918 · 1 season1916 · 1 season
Rivington Bisland—1914 · 1 season1912 · 1 season
Harry Davis—1912 · 1 season1897 · 1 season
Billy Clingman—1903 · 1 season1895 · 1 season
Bill HofferP1901 · 1 season1899 · 1 season
Frank Genins—1901 · 1 season1895 · 1 season

Regular season, under every name each club has played as. A season split by a trade counts for both clubs where the game logs reach it (NBA from 1993-94, NFL 1994, NHL 1996, MLB 2001). Longest stay with the two first.

Cleveland Guardians vs Pittsburgh Pirates: head-to-head record →