Players who played for the Cleveland Guardians and New York Yankees
205 players
205 players have played for both the Cleveland Guardians and the New York Yankees. CC Sabathia spent the most seasons with the two: 8 with the Cleveland Guardians and 11 with the New York Yankees. On a roster now: Amed Rosario, Enyel De Los Santos, and Jake Bauers. Every season since 1876 is on file.
| Player | Pos | CLE | NYY |
|---|---|---|---|
| CC Sabathia | SP | 2001–2008 · 8 seasons | 2009–2019 · 11 seasons |
| Graig Nettles | 3B | 1970–1972 · 3 seasons | 1973–1983 · 11 seasons |
| Joe Sewell | — | 1920–1930 · 11 seasons | 1931–1933 · 3 seasons |
| Steve O'Neill | — | 1911–1923 · 13 seasons | 1925 · 1 season |
| Carlos Carrasco | RP | 2009–2024 · 12 seasons | 2025 · 1 season |
| Allie Reynolds | P | 1942–1946 · 5 seasons | 1947–1954 · 8 seasons |
| Lou Piniella | DH | 1968 · 1 season | 1974–1984 · 11 seasons |
| Sam McDowell | P | 1961–1971 · 11 seasons | 1974 · 1 season |
| George Uhle | P | 1919–1936 · 11 seasons | 1934 · 1 season |
| Travis Hafner | DH | 2003–2012 · 10 seasons | 2013 · 1 season |
| Kenny Lofton | LF | 1992–2007 · 10 seasons | 2004 · 1 season |
| Joe Gordon | — | 1947–1950 · 4 seasons | 1938–1946 · 7 seasons |
| Aaron Ward | — | 1928 · 1 season | 1917–1926 · 10 seasons |
| Ray Caldwell | P | 1920–1921 · 2 seasons | 1910–1918 · 9 seasons |
| Roger Peckinpaugh | — | 1910–1912 · 2 seasons | 1913–1921 · 9 seasons |
| Corey Kluber | SP | 2011–2019 · 9 seasons | 2021 · 1 season |
| Jake Westbrook | SP | 2001–2010 · 9 seasons | 2000 · 1 season |
| Gene Woodling | — | 1943–1957 · 4 seasons | 1949–1954 · 6 seasons |
| Stan Coveleski | P | 1916–1924 · 9 seasons | 1928 · 1 season |
| Zach McAllister | RP | 2011–2018 · 8 seasons | 2023 · 1 season |
| Jason Giambi | DH | 2013–2014 · 2 seasons | 2002–2008 · 7 seasons |
| Bob Wickman | RP | 2001–2006 · 5 seasons | 1992–1995 · 4 seasons |
| Dave Winfield | DH | 1995 · 1 season | 1981–1988 · 8 seasons |
| Rick Cerone | C | 1975–1976 · 2 seasons | 1980–1990 · 7 seasons |
| Tommy John | SP | 1963–1964 · 2 seasons | 1979–1989 · 7 seasons |
| Chris Chambliss | 1B | 1971–1973 · 3 seasons | 1975–1988 · 6 seasons |
| Oscar Gamble | DH | 1973–1975 · 3 seasons | 1976–1984 · 6 seasons |
| Fred Stanley | SS | 1971 · 1 season | 1973–1980 · 8 seasons |
| Fritz Peterson | P | 1975 · 1 season | 1966–1973 · 8 seasons |
| Roy Weatherly | — | 1936–1942 · 7 seasons | 1943–1946 · 2 seasons |
| Johnny Allen | P | 1936–1940 · 5 seasons | 1932–1935 · 4 seasons |
| Monte Pearson | P | 1932–1935 · 4 seasons | 1936–1940 · 5 seasons |
| Joba Chamberlain | RP | 2016 · 1 season | 2007–2013 · 7 seasons |
| Jaret Wright | SP | 1997–2002 · 6 seasons | 2005–2006 · 2 seasons |
| Eric Plunk | RP | 1992–1997 · 6 seasons | 1990–1991 · 2 seasons |
| Mel Hall | LF | 1985–1988 · 4 seasons | 1989–1992 · 4 seasons |
| Luis Tiant | SP | 1964–1969 · 6 seasons | 1979–1980 · 2 seasons |
| Roger Maris | — | 1957 · 1 season | 1960–1966 · 7 seasons |
| Snuffy Stirnweiss | — | 1951 · 1 season | 1943–1949 · 7 seasons |
| Myril Hoag | — | 1945 · 1 season | 1931–1938 · 7 seasons |
| Oscar Grimes | — | 1938–1942 · 5 seasons | 1943–1945 · 3 seasons |
| Ben Chapman | — | 1939–1940 · 2 seasons | 1930–1935 · 6 seasons |
| Oral Hildebrand | P | 1931–1936 · 6 seasons | 1939–1940 · 2 seasons |
| Wes Ferrell | P | 1927–1933 · 7 seasons | 1939 · 1 season |
| Nick Swisher | LF | 2013–2015 · 3 seasons | 2009–2012 · 4 seasons |
| David Huff | RP | 2009–2013 · 5 seasons | 2013–2014 · 2 seasons |
| Alvaro Espinoza | SS | 1993–1995 · 3 seasons | 1988–1991 · 4 seasons |
| Ron Hassey | C | 1978–1983 · 6 seasons | 1985 · 1 season |
| John Ellis | — | 1973–1975 · 3 seasons | 1969–1972 · 4 seasons |
| Steve Hamilton | P | 1961 · 1 season | 1964–1969 · 6 seasons |
| Ralph Terry | P | 1965 · 1 season | 1956–1964 · 6 seasons |
| Woodie Held | — | 1959–1964 · 6 seasons | 1954 · 1 season |
| Billy Martin | — | 1959 · 1 season | 1950–1956 · 6 seasons |
| Red Embree | P | 1941–1947 · 6 seasons | 1948 · 1 season |
| Bill Zuber | P | 1936–1940 · 4 seasons | 1943–1945 · 3 seasons |
| Bill Knickerbocker | — | 1933–1936 · 4 seasons | 1938–1940 · 3 seasons |
| Lyn Lary | — | 1937–1938 · 2 seasons | 1929–1933 · 5 seasons |
| Ben Paschal | — | 1915 · 1 season | 1924–1929 · 6 seasons |
| Sam Jones | P | 1914–1915 · 2 seasons | 1922–1926 · 5 seasons |
| Chick Fewster | — | 1924–1925 · 2 seasons | 1917–1921 · 5 seasons |
| Les Nunamaker | — | 1919–1922 · 4 seasons | 1915–1917 · 3 seasons |
| Greg Allen | CF | 2017–2020 · 4 seasons | 2021–2023 · 2 seasons |
| Melky Cabrera | RF | 2018 · 1 season | 2005–2009 · 5 seasons |
| Shelley Duncan | 1B | 2010–2012 · 3 seasons | 2007–2009 · 3 seasons |
| Bartolo Colon | SP | 1997–2001 · 5 seasons | 2011 · 1 season |
| Steve Karsay | RP | 1998–2000 · 3 seasons | 2002–2005 · 3 seasons |
| Enrique Wilson | 2B | 1997–1999 · 3 seasons | 2002–2004 · 3 seasons |
| Shane Spencer | LF | 2003 · 1 season | 1998–2002 · 5 seasons |
| Mike Fischlin | SS | 1981–1985 · 5 seasons | 1986 · 1 season |
| Toby Harrah | 2B | 1979–1983 · 5 seasons | 1984 · 1 season |
| Dick Tidrow | RP | 1972–1973 · 2 seasons | 1975–1978 · 4 seasons |
| Charlie Spikes | CF | 1973–1977 · 5 seasons | 1972 · 1 season |
| Jerry Kenney | — | 1973 · 1 season | 1967–1972 · 5 seasons |
| Stan Williams | P | 1965–1969 · 4 seasons | 1963–1964 · 2 seasons |
| Bud Daley | P | 1955–1957 · 3 seasons | 1962–1964 · 3 seasons |
| Eddie Robinson | — | 1942–1948 · 4 seasons | 1954–1955 · 2 seasons |
| Buddy Rosar | — | 1943–1944 · 2 seasons | 1939–1942 · 4 seasons |
| Rollie Hemsley | — | 1938–1941 · 4 seasons | 1943–1944 · 2 seasons |
| Jumbo Brown | P | 1927–1928 · 2 seasons | 1932–1936 · 4 seasons |
| Roxy Walters | — | 1924–1925 · 2 seasons | 1915–1918 · 4 seasons |
| Elmer Smith | — | 1914–1921 · 5 seasons | 1923 · 1 season |
| Amed Rosario | 3B | 2021–2023 · 3 seasons | 2025–2026 · 2 seasons |
| Gio Urshela | 3B | 2015–2017 · 2 seasons | 2019–2021 · 3 seasons |
| Andrew Miller | RP | 2016–2018 · 3 seasons | 2015–2016 · 2 seasons |
| Boone Logan | RP | 2017 · 1 season | 2010–2013 · 4 seasons |
| Johnny Damon | LF | 2012 · 1 season | 2006–2009 · 4 seasons |
| Aaron Laffey | SP | 2007–2010 · 4 seasons | 2011 · 1 season |
| Jose Veras | RP | 2009 · 1 season | 2006–2009 · 4 seasons |
| Jason Grimsley | RP | 1993–1995 · 3 seasons | 1999–2000 · 2 seasons |
| Mark Whiten | CF | 1992–2000 · 4 seasons | 1997 · 1 season |
| Dion James | LF | 1990 · 1 season | 1992–1996 · 4 seasons |
| Neal Heaton | RP | 1982–1985 · 4 seasons | 1993 · 1 season |
| Joel Skinner | C | 1989–1991 · 3 seasons | 1987–1988 · 2 seasons |
| Otis Nixon | LF | 1984–1987 · 4 seasons | 1983 · 1 season |
| Dave LaRoche | RP | 1975–1976 · 2 seasons | 1981–1983 · 3 seasons |
| Otto Velez | DH | 1983 · 1 season | 1973–1976 · 4 seasons |
| Dick Howser | — | 1964–1966 · 3 seasons | 1967–1968 · 2 seasons |
| Johnny Broaca | P | 1939 · 1 season | 1934–1937 · 4 seasons |
| Ed Klepfer | P | 1916–1919 · 3 seasons | 1911–1913 · 2 seasons |
| Tim Hendryx | — | 1911–1912 · 2 seasons | 1915–1917 · 3 seasons |
| Tyler Clippard | RP | 2019 · 1 season | 2007–2017 · 3 seasons |
| Ben Francisco | LF | 2007–2009 · 3 seasons | 2013 · 1 season |
| Carl Pavano | SP | 2009 · 1 season | 2005–2008 · 3 seasons |
| Dave Dellucci | LF | 2007–2009 · 3 seasons | 2003 · 1 season |
| Richie Sexson | 1B | 1997–1999 · 3 seasons | 2008 · 1 season |
| Alan Embree | RP | 1992–1996 · 3 seasons | 2005 · 1 season |
| Jesse Orosco | RP | 1989–1991 · 3 seasons | 2003 · 1 season |
| David Justice | LF | 1997–1999 · 3 seasons | 2001 · 1 season |
| Dwight Gooden | RP | 1998–1999 · 2 seasons | 1996–1997 · 2 seasons |
| Steve Farr | RP | 1984 · 1 season | 1991–1993 · 3 seasons |
| Paul Zuvella | 3B | 1988–1989 · 2 seasons | 1986–1987 · 2 seasons |
| Mike Armstrong | RP | 1987 · 1 season | 1984–1986 · 3 seasons |
| Phil Niekro | SP | 1986–1987 · 2 seasons | 1984–1985 · 2 seasons |
| Rick Dempsey | C | 1987 · 1 season | 1973–1975 · 3 seasons |
| Pat Dobson | P | 1976–1977 · 2 seasons | 1974–1975 · 2 seasons |
| Tom Buskey | RP | 1975–1977 · 3 seasons | 1973 · 1 season |
| Rusty Torres | DH | 1973–1974 · 2 seasons | 1971–1972 · 2 seasons |
| Pedro Gonzalez | — | 1966–1967 · 2 seasons | 1963–1964 · 2 seasons |
| Pedro Ramos | P | 1962–1963 · 2 seasons | 1965–1966 · 2 seasons |
| Bob Kuzava | P | 1946–1947 · 2 seasons | 1952–1953 · 2 seasons |
| Allie Clark | — | 1948–1950 · 3 seasons | 1947 · 1 season |
| Chick Autry | — | 1926–1928 · 3 seasons | 1924 · 1 season |
| Braggo Roth | — | 1916–1918 · 3 seasons | 1921 · 1 season |
| Neal Ball | — | 1910–1911 · 2 seasons | 1907–1908 · 2 seasons |
| Deacon McGuire | — | 1910 · 1 season | 1904–1906 · 3 seasons |
| Frank Delahanty | — | 1907 · 1 season | 1905–1908 · 3 seasons |
| Walter Clarkson | P | 1908 · 1 season | 1904–1906 · 3 seasons |
| Enyel De Los Santos | RP | 2022–2023 · 2 seasons | 2024 · 1 season |
| Josh Donaldson | 3B | 2018 · 1 season | 2022–2023 · 2 seasons |
| Edwin Encarnacion | DH | 2017–2018 · 2 seasons | 2019 · 1 season |
| George Kontos | RP | 2018 · 1 season | 2011–2018 · 2 seasons |
| Esmil Rogers | RP | 2012 · 1 season | 2014–2015 · 2 seasons |
| Chris Dickerson | LF | 2014 · 1 season | 2011–2012 · 2 seasons |
| Jayson Nix | SS | 2010 · 1 season | 2012–2013 · 2 seasons |
| Austin Kearns | RF | 2010–2011 · 2 seasons | 2010 · 1 season |
| Kerry Wood | RP | 2009–2010 · 2 seasons | 2010 · 1 season |
| Joe Borowski | RP | 2007–2008 · 2 seasons | 1998 · 1 season |
| Jim Brower | RP | 1999–2000 · 2 seasons | 2007 · 1 season |
| Ron Villone | RP | 1998 · 1 season | 2006–2007 · 2 seasons |
| Aaron Boone | 3B | 2005–2006 · 2 seasons | 2003 · 1 season |
| Jason Anderson | RP | 2004 · 1 season | 2003–2005 · 2 seasons |
| Karim Garcia | RF | 2001–2003 · 2 seasons | 2003 · 1 season |
| Jack McDowell | SP | 1996–1997 · 2 seasons | 1995 · 1 season |
| Brad Arnsberg | RP | 1992 · 1 season | 1986–1987 · 2 seasons |
| Brian Dorsett | C | 1987 · 1 season | 1989–1990 · 2 seasons |
| Tim Stoddard | RP | 1989 · 1 season | 1987–1988 · 2 seasons |
| Wendell Alston | DH | 1979–1980 · 2 seasons | 1977 · 1 season |
| Fred Beene | P | 1975 · 1 season | 1972–1973 · 2 seasons |
| Walt Williams | — | 1973 · 1 season | 1974–1975 · 2 seasons |
| Rob Gardner | P | 1968 · 1 season | 1970–1972 · 2 seasons |
| Butch Wensloff | P | 1948 · 1 season | 1943–1947 · 2 seasons |
| Sherm Lollar | — | 1946 · 1 season | 1947–1948 · 2 seasons |
| Al Gettel | P | 1947 · 1 season | 1945–1946 · 2 seasons |
| Buster Mills | — | 1942–1946 · 2 seasons | 1940 · 1 season |
| Bob Seeds | — | 1930–1931 · 2 seasons | 1936 · 1 season |
| Pete Appleton | P | 1930–1931 · 2 seasons | 1933 · 1 season |
| Harvey Hendrick | — | 1925 · 1 season | 1923–1924 · 2 seasons |
| Joe Harris | — | 1917–1919 · 2 seasons | 1914 · 1 season |
| Nick Cullop | P | 1913 · 1 season | 1916–1917 · 2 seasons |
| Wilbur Good | — | 1908–1909 · 2 seasons | 1905 · 1 season |
| Jim Jackson | — | 1905–1906 · 2 seasons | 1901 · 1 season |
| Jake Bauers | 1B | 2019 · 1 season | 2023 · 1 season |
| Blake Parker | RP | 2021 · 1 season | 2016 · 1 season |
| Jay Bruce | LF | 2017 · 1 season | 2021 · 1 season |
| A.J. Cole | RP | 2019 · 1 season | 2018 · 1 season |
| Anthony Swarzak | RP | 2015 · 1 season | 2016 · 1 season |
| Josh Outman | RP | 2014 · 1 season | 2014 · 1 season |
| Rich Hill | SP | 2013 · 1 season | 2014 · 1 season |
| Brent Lillibridge | SS | 2012 · 1 season | 2013 · 1 season |
| Clay Rapada | RP | 2013 · 1 season | 2012 · 1 season |
| Mark Reynolds | 1B | 2013 · 1 season | 2013 · 1 season |
| Thomas Neal | LF | 2012 · 1 season | 2013 · 1 season |
| Derek Lowe | RP | 2012 · 1 season | 2012 · 1 season |
| Luis Vizcaino | RP | 2009 · 1 season | 2007 · 1 season |
| Billy Traber | SP | 2003 · 1 season | 2008 · 1 season |
| Sal Fasano | C | 2008 · 1 season | 2006 · 1 season |
| Josh Phelps | 1B | 2004 · 1 season | 2007 · 1 season |
| Dan Miceli | RP | 2003 · 1 season | 2003 · 1 season |
| Terry Mulholland | RP | 2003 · 1 season | 1994 · 1 season |
| Chris Turner | C | 1999 · 1 season | 2000 · 1 season |
| Ryan Thompson | LF | 1996 · 1 season | 2000 · 1 season |
| Torey Lovullo | 1B | 1998 · 1 season | 1991 · 1 season |
| Tony Fernandez | DH | 1997 · 1 season | 1995 · 1 season |
| Bob Ojeda | SP | 1993 · 1 season | 1994 · 1 season |
| Cecilio Guante | RP | 1990 · 1 season | 1987 · 1 season |
| Rafael Santana | SS | 1990 · 1 season | 1988 · 1 season |
| Tom Brookens | 3B | 1990 · 1 season | 1989 · 1 season |
| Neil Allen | RP | 1989 · 1 season | 1988 · 1 season |
| Ron Kittle | 1B | 1988 · 1 season | 1987 · 1 season |
| Jeff Moronko | 3B | 1984 · 1 season | 1987 · 1 season |
| Ed Whitson | SP | 1982 · 1 season | 1985 · 1 season |
| Bobby Bonds | CF | 1979 · 1 season | 1975 · 1 season |
| Alex Johnson | — | 1972 · 1 season | 1975 · 1 season |
| Jerry Moses | — | 1972 · 1 season | 1973 · 1 season |
| Al Cicotte | P | 1959 · 1 season | 1957 · 1 season |
| Bob Muncrief | P | 1948 · 1 season | 1951 · 1 season |
| Eddie Bockman | — | 1947 · 1 season | 1946 · 1 season |
| Eddie Phillips | — | 1935 · 1 season | 1932 · 1 season |
| Germany Schaefer | — | 1918 · 1 season | 1916 · 1 season |
| Clyde Engle | — | 1916 · 1 season | 1909 · 1 season |
| Ernie Krueger | — | 1913 · 1 season | 1915 · 1 season |
| Jack Lelivelt | — | 1914 · 1 season | 1912 · 1 season |
| Gus Fisher | — | 1911 · 1 season | 1912 · 1 season |
| Harry Ables | P | 1909 · 1 season | 1911 · 1 season |
| Mike Donovan | — | 1904 · 1 season | 1908 · 1 season |
Regular season, under every name each club has played as. A season split by a trade counts for both clubs where the game logs reach it (NBA from 1993-94, NFL 1994, NHL 1996, MLB 2001). Longest stay with the two first.
Cleveland Guardians vs New York Yankees: head-to-head record →