Players who played for the Indianapolis Colts and New York Jets
40 players
40 players have played for both the Indianapolis Colts and the New York Jets. Jack Trudeau spent the most seasons with the two: 8 with the Indianapolis Colts and 1 with the New York Jets. On a roster now: Sauce Gardner, Adonai Mitchell, Spencer Shrader, Joe Flacco, and Chase McLaughlin. Rosters are on file in full from 1993; before that only some of the stars are.
| Player | Pos | IND | NYJ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jack Trudeau | QB | 1986–1993 · 8 seasons | 1994 · 1 season |
| Sauce Gardner | CB | 2025–2026 · 2 seasons | 2022–2025 · 4 seasons |
| Antonio Cromartie | DB | 2016 · 1 season | 2010–2015 · 5 seasons |
| Matthias Farley | S | 2016–2018 · 3 seasons | 2019–2020 · 2 seasons |
| Daniel Muir | DT | 2008–2011 · 4 seasons | 2012 · 1 season |
| Donald Strickland | CB | 2003–2005 · 3 seasons | 2009–2011 · 2 seasons |
| Ben Hartsock | TE | 2004–2006 · 3 seasons | 2009–2010 · 2 seasons |
| Cary Blanchard | PK | 1995–1997 · 3 seasons | 1992–1993 · 2 seasons |
| Anthony Johnson | RB | 1990–1993 · 4 seasons | 1994 · 1 season |
| Adonai Mitchell | WR | 2024–2025 · 2 seasons | 2025–2026 · 2 seasons |
| Spencer Shrader | PK | 2024–2026 · 3 seasons | 2024 · 1 season |
| Joe Flacco | QB | 2024 · 1 season | 2020–2022 · 3 seasons |
| Frank Gore | RB | 2015–2017 · 3 seasons | 2020 · 1 season |
| Pierre Desir | CB | 2017–2019 · 3 seasons | 2020 · 1 season |
| Dwight Lowery | S | 2015 · 1 season | 2008–2010 · 3 seasons |
| Jamaal Westerman | LB | 2012 · 1 season | 2009–2011 · 3 seasons |
| Steve Martin | DT | 1996–1998 · 3 seasons | 2001 · 1 season |
| Tom Tupa | P | 1992 · 1 season | 1999–2001 · 3 seasons |
| Browning Kenneth Nagle | QB | 1994 · 1 season | 1991–1993 · 3 seasons |
| Al Woods | DT | 2017–2018 · 2 seasons | 2023 · 1 season |
| Chase McLaughlin | PK | 2019–2022 · 2 seasons | 2020 · 1 season |
| Jonotthan Harrison | C | 2014–2015 · 2 seasons | 2019 · 1 season |
| LaRon Landry | FS | 2013–2014 · 2 seasons | 2012 · 1 season |
| Doug Brien | PK | 2001 · 1 season | 2003–2004 · 2 seasons |
| Tony Stargell | DB | 1992–1993 · 2 seasons | 1990 · 1 season |
| Jelani Woods | TE | 2022 · 1 season | 2025 · 1 season |
| Samuel Womack III | CB | 2024 · 1 season | 2025 · 1 season |
| D.J. Montgomery | WR | 2023 · 1 season | 2021 · 1 season |
| Jacob Martin | DE | 2023 · 1 season | 2022 · 1 season |
| J.J. Wilcox | S | 2018 · 1 season | 2018 · 1 season |
| Anthony Johnson | DE | 2017 · 1 season | 2016 · 1 season |
| Josh Thomas | CB | 2015 · 1 season | 2014 · 1 season |
| A.J. Edds | LB | 2011 · 1 season | 2014 · 1 season |
| Joshua Cribbs | WR | 2014 · 1 season | 2013 · 1 season |
| Martin Tevaseu | DT | 2012 · 1 season | 2011 · 1 season |
| Jeremy Kapinos | P | 2010 · 1 season | 2007 · 1 season |
| Luke Lawton | FB | 2007 · 1 season | 2005 · 1 season |
| Jermaine Wiggins | TE | 2002 · 1 season | 2000 · 1 season |
| Rob Holmberg | LB | 1998 · 1 season | 1998 · 1 season |
| Jeff Faulkner | DE | 1990 · 1 season | 1996 · 1 season |
Regular season, under every name each club has played as. A season split by a trade counts for both clubs where the game logs reach it (NBA from 1993-94, NFL 1994, NHL 1996, MLB 2001). Longest stay with the two first.